hidden image

A Blow to Liberty

Joseph Maliakan Joseph Maliakan
11 Jan 2021

Following his resignation from the Atal Behari Vajpayee’s Ministry on August 1, 1998, Ram Jethmalani, in his statement in the Rajya Sabha, said: “To say that making or keeping copies of one’s own correspondence is theft will shock the dumbest law student. 

Even a cursory reading of the January 4 judgment of a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court comprising Justices A. Hariprasad and K. Haripal setting aside the bail granted to journalism student Thwaha Fasal by the Kochi NIA Court in the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) case “will shock the dumbest law student.”

While the bail order of the NIA court judge Anil K. Bhaskar is based on close examination of the prosecution submissions, rational arguments and legal precedents, the High Court order seems to be based on misplaced nationalist sentiments.

In fact, every court in the country exists to be on the side of the common man who needs constant protection against executive insolence, corruption and incompetence. However, the Kerala High Court order in the UAPA case apparently suffers from legal infirmities. Commenting on the order, Gautam Bhatia, a leading legal critic, wrote: “You are guilty if there is evidence against you. You are also guilty if there is no evidence against you, because that only shows how good you are at operating surreptitiously. The state always wins.”
Italian philosopher Giorgio Agamben, years ago, wrote: “The voluntary creation of a permanent state of emergency has become one of the essential practices of contemporary states, including the so-called democratic ones -- radically erasing the legal status of the individual thus producing a legally unnamable and unclassifiable being. Neither prisoners, nor accused, but simply detainees, they are objects of a pure de facto rule.”

In the name of national security, extraordinary draconian laws meant to deal with extraordinary situations have become part of the new normal. While TADA and POTA have disappeared, the UAPA 1967 (every Indian should remember that the law has been on our statute books for more than  half a century and we did nothing to repeal it) was revived with lethal amendments and has been for more than 12 years now an oppressive feature of the governments, both at the Centre and the States, irrespective of the party in power. 
People have only the courts for protection from the oppressive over-reach of state power and the Indian courts have been by and large protective of individual liberty. It is under these circumstances that one finds the latest Kerala High Court ruling in the UAPA bail case very alarming.

Two students, Allan Shuaib and Thwaha Fasal, were arrested by the Kerala police in November 2019 under the UAPA alleging that they were supporting proscribed Maoist groups, which have been declared as terrorist organizations. Later, the NIA took over the case. 
Granting bail to the two students on September 9, 2020, a special NIA court in Kochi said the mere possession of Maoist literature, presence in anti-government protests or strong political beliefs do not make a person complicit in terrorist activity.

In his bail order, NIA Judge Anil K. Bhasker said: “Considering the facts and circumstances of this case, balancing  the aggravating and mitigating circumstances, and taking care of the competing rival interests, I find the judicial discretion available with this court, is to be exercised in granting bail to both petitioners.” 

The NIA court found that most of the documents seized from the homes of the two students were freely available in the public domain. The court observed that none of the documents pertain to any violent terrorist activity by the two arrested students.

“The documents prima facie do not indicate any attempt to excite the people to violently protest against the government.’’ the order pointed out. “Right to protest is a constitutionally guaranteed right …. a protest against policies and decisions of the government, even if it is for a wrong cause cannot be termed as sedition or an intentional act to support cession or secession,” the judge added.

The “objectionable writings” produced as evidence against the accused students were not banned and did not prove “any attempt to create any hatred or contempt to the government of India nor does it excite any disaffection,” the order said.

Setting aside the excellently reasoned order of the NIA court, the two honorable High Court judges instead of complimenting him has issued a warning in the concluding paragraph of their order: “We would also like to remind the learned judge that the impugned order has been prepared as if it is a court of record which was unnecessary. Similarly, the learned Judge, while quoting some judgments of the Apex Court, has stated the names of the Hon’ble Judges who authored the judgments which is unwholesome.”

Do our Lordships realize that “unwholesome” means damaging for your life, either physically, morally or emotionally. The oppressed and marginalized people of India will find the NIA Judge Bhaskar’s order quite wholesome.
 

Recent Posts

Dr Randall Sequeira's arrest raises questions about the criminalisation of solidarity with Adivasi communities resisting mining projects. As a doctor who chose service over comfort, his case highlight
apicture Jubel D'Cruz
16 Nov 2026
From pioneering healthcare and education to the freedom struggle, social reform and nation-building, Indian Christians have contributed immensely to the country's progress. Yet, their legacy of servic
apicture P. A. Chacko
16 Nov 2026
Sonia Gandhi's Belonging offers an intimate account of a life shaped by love, loss, duty and political upheaval. It challenges the persistent myths cooked up against her while also reflecting on India
apicture A. J. Philip
16 Nov 2026
The US midterm elections offer India an important democratic lesson: political power is never permanent, and no leader is above public scrutiny. A strong opposition, accountable government, independen
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
16 Nov 2026
Uttar Pradesh is the Congress's ultimate test of national relevance. Rebuilding its fractured coalition, addressing grievances and negotiating credible alliances are essential if it hopes to regain re
apicture John Dayal
16 Nov 2026
India's political leadership has consistently avoided unscripted public debates, hiding behind parliamentary conventions. Rahul Gandhi's challenge to Narendra Modi revives an important democratic ques
apicture Jijo Thomas Placheril
16 Nov 2026
India's fisheries boom must translate into better lives for those who sustain it. Rising production and exports mean little when traditional fishers face mounting debts, climate risks and inadequate s
apicture Jose Vattakuzhy
16 Nov 2026
Adopted from Kolkata as a toddler, Italian nurse Ramona Tratter returns to her birth country to bring healthcare and hope to marginalised communities in Bengal.
apicture CM Paul
16 Nov 2026
There's a wonderful convenience to changing a name. You can invite the press, pull a cord and have a photograph of the job being done.
apicture Robert Clements
16 Nov 2026
From Serbia to Brazil, Israel, the United States and India, people are challenging authoritarianism, corruption, communalism and war. A global awakening is gathering momentum, with youth-led movements
apicture Cedric Prakash
09 Nov 2026