hidden image

Duplicity of Our Talk

Balvinder Balvinder
06 Nov 2023

Whatever the political compulsions may be, India's abstention from the recent UN resolution calling for an "immediate, durable and sustained humanitarian truce leading to cessation of hostilities" in Gaza is shockingly painful.

More so because UN being a toothless institution, its resolution has only a symbolic value. And the alibi for abstention -- non-inclusion of condemnation of Hamas’ terrorist acts -- is simply silly.

Leave aside the current Gaza conflict, India has never given even two hoots for humane values. We have endless examples of our own bloody conflicts that begin from Mahabharata to deadly Kalinga war to bloody 1947 divide to 1984 genocide to 2002 Gujarat riots to the ongoing Manipur mayhem! 

The time has probably come we should stop calling ourselves a peace-loving country that gave birth to the likes of Gautama Buddha, Guru Nanak and Gandhiji. 

Perhaps we have always been a country of hypocrites who never cherished humane values. 

We forget that Buddha (circa 528 BCE), Guru Nanak (15th century) and Gandhi (20th century) raised their voices in favour of humane values only after seeing inhuman acts being enacted around them during the life times of each of them. 

I wonder how come the Mauryan King Ashoka (circa 304 -- 232 BCE) became Ashoka the Great? Only because he adopted Buddhism? 

We should not forget that Ashoka adopted Buddhism only after initiating a bloody war of Kalinga in which more than one lakh people were killed and one and a half times more people were deported, or say made homeless! 

At times it seems that hypocrisy has been running in our blood since the distant past, and perhaps it can never be changed. 

However, on a closer look at the past and present history of India (Bharat?), one can see that this bad blood has not been running in the blood of common Indians. It has always been a prerogative of the ruling class alone! 

One can recall here an oft repeated story of Panchatantra, the Scorpion and the frog, which talks of a benevolent frog who being of an inherently helpful nature offers help to a venomous scorpion. But the scorpion, in return, bites the helping frog, as per his own vicious nature. 

All our rulers, from past till date, can perhaps be compared to cold-blooded scorpions and the innocent and helping common people to frogs.

Had the world ever given attention to the advices of the sages like Jesus Christ, Buddha and Nanak, who preached and sacrificed their lives for humane values, the world would have been a real heaven. 

(The writer is former Principal of Chandigarh's first Government College)

Recent Posts

A diplomatic dinner is more than a meal; it is cultural diplomacy on a plate. India has every right to showcase its magnificent vegetarian cuisine, but excluding its equally rich non-vegetarian tradit
apicture A. J. Philip
21 Sep 2026
Ageing need not mean becoming a burden. With the right opportunities, senior citizens can remain productive, creative and socially engaged. Kerala's emerging Silver Economy offers the Church and civil
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
21 Sep 2026
Congress asked Karnataka's Christians to trust its promise to repeal the anti-conversion law. Three years later, the law remains. Repeated meetings, assurances and memoranda have only served to produc
apicture John Dayal
21 Sep 2026
Accountability is travelling from official files to the grassroots. "School Thik Karo" may be satire's latest avatar, but its questions about India's public schools are real.
apicture Pachu Menon
21 Sep 2026
India's education system is in terminal decline because of short-sightedness and corrupt, incompetent academic leadership. The public education system is practically dismantled. Ever since the Nationa
apicture G Ramachandram
21 Sep 2026
A major strength of the book is that Menamparampil does not examine these issues merely as political or theological problems. He approaches them through human relationships, collective identities, soc
apicture K. Jose, SVD
21 Sep 2026
I am tired of the Indian theorists MN Srinivas, Bhikku Parekh, Ashish Nandy, Akeel Bilgrami,
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
21 Sep 2026
The voter is sovereign. The electoral roll exists for the voter. The election exists for the voter. The government ultimately derives legitimacy from the voter. When crores disappear from electoral ro
apicture Oliver D'Souza
21 Sep 2026
The Bible is filled with rulers who believed they could contain God. Today, their thrones are gone, their empires are history, and many of their names are remembered only because they tried to stop Hi
apicture Robert Clements
21 Sep 2026
India's daughters are still treated as someone else's property, burdened by patriarchy, denied autonomy and forced to surrender independence. Rahul Gandhi's women-only gathering in Pune challenged thi
apicture G Ramachandram
14 Sep 2026