hidden image

Laboratory of Hate

Mathew John Mathew John
19 Dec 2022
In a world of unremitting barbarities, we need to be reminded of what happened to Bilkis Bano’s family in those hellish days of national disgrace and infamy in 2002 that claimed over 1900 lives and resulted in widespread destruction of homes and prop

In Mary Shelley’s novel by that name, Frankenstein created a monster in a laboratory over a two-year period, based on an abstruse but deadly effective scientific principle, and this bogeyman (always a ‘man’) went on to wreak death and destruction wherever he went. I was reminded of this macabre tale as the results of the Gujarat Assembly elections were trumpeted across the country last week.

More than two decades ago during Vajpayee’s reign, the country first witnessed planned, targeted violence against minorities, with Gujarat as the epicentre. The now forgotten VHP leader, Praveen Togadia then proudly proclaimed Gujarat as the laboratory of Hindutva -- the gospel of majoritarianism. That was the time when there were coordinated attacks on Muslims and Christians -- assaults on their places of worship, burial grounds, schools, gatherings and businesses -- accompanied by the boastful refrain: “Now that our government is in power, we can do what we want.” 

But the constraints of coalition politics, the outcry from still independent constitutional bodies and media, and the benign persona of Vajpayee hampered, to an extent, the vigilante squads let loose by the Hindu Dharma Jagran Manch (HJM). The indignation and uproar over the attacks on minorities forced Vajpayee, in January 1999, to visit Dangs, the hotbed of violence against minorities, and order punitive action against erring government officials. Unlike today, there was considerable resistance to majoritarian bigotry at that time, prompting the VHP leader, Giriraj Kishore, to lament that “the Hindu agenda was limping on crutches.”

Gujarat has travelled a long way. The double-engine ruling dispensation has dropped even the pretence of being secular or of honoring the country’s composite culture. Having captured the collective Hindu consciousness, it now flaunts Hindutva with a swagger. There is an unabashed State-sponsored assertion of Hindu identity and the cancelling out of the minorities, particularly Muslims.

At an election rally a few days before Gujarat went to the polls, Amit Shah justified the horrific happenings in Gujarat in 2002, belligerently stating that “they (?) were taught such a lesson that since then the state has not witnessed a single case of communal violence,” cunningly targeting a community without elaborating who “they” were. My God, the Home Minister of the country was not only extolling evil, but sowing hatred of one’s fellow countrymen to garner votes! It is important to note his choice of locale when making this most inflammatory, cynical evaluation of the darkest period in our recent history. On 22nd November, he was appealing to the electorate to support the BJP candidate, Payal Kukrani, whose father was convicted in the horrific massacre of Bilkis Bano’s family during the genocidal killings in Gujarat in 2002.  By nominating her, the ruling party, defying ordinary decency and ethics, conveyed the message that the killers were men of honour! 

In a world of unremitting barbarities, we need to be reminded of what happened to Bilkis Bano’s family in those hellish days of national disgrace and infamy in 2002 that claimed over 1900 lives and resulted in widespread destruction of homes and property, mostly Muslim. Bilkis Bano, then 19 years old, was attacked and gang-raped by a mob as were her mother and two sisters. As she lay battered and bleeding on the floor, the brutes took a stone and smashed the head of her infant daughter Saleha, for which act alone they deserved death and eternal damnation! Bilkis lost 14 members of her family that day. Such spine-chilling, gruesome butchery played out across Gujarat during that period of horrendous savagery.

The heroic Bilkis, despite heartbreak that would have killed even the doughtiest, and undeterred by having to change her home numerous times just to escape being silenced, fought for justice and with rock-like support of activists such as Teesta Setalvad, succeeded in securing the conviction in 2008 of the 11 men guilty of the gang-rape and murder of members of Bano’s family. The convictions restored hope in our secular democracy and the foundational principle that the law would be applied equally to all, irrespective of the religious stripes one wears. We dared to hope that it would bring a closure to the nightmare spawned by Gujarat 2002 and that Hindus and Muslims would once again live together in peace. But it was hoping against hope in a milieu where the most daunting political leviathan ever in this country, whips up hate to win elections!  

How we respond to tragedy reveals our national character, our community culture and most importantly, our humanity.  Today, the murderous hate and distrust between communities have hardened, fomented by a formidable cultural outfit and its political surrogate. Hindutva’s gospel of belligerent homogeneity and exclusion have assertively settled in the innards of the nation. The whole lot of institutions – the bureaucracy, the law-enforcement agencies, even the judiciary -- have become choir boys of the saffron ensemble.

Look at what has transpired in the momentous Bilkis Bano case. The eleven savages who raped, ravaged and destroyed the Bano family were all released from jail, significantly on 15th August this year even as the PM thundered on about ‘nari shakti’ from the ramparts of the Red Fort. While the advertised official version has it that the out-of-turn release of the convicts was ordered by the Gujarat government, under its remission policy, the Supreme Court actually facilitated the release by directing the State government to consider the remission petition in terms of its policy  of 1992 that was in force on the date of conviction, and not on the basis of the state government’s revised policy of 2014 which bars out-of-turn release of prisoners convicted for rape and murder. Had the extant policy been invoked, the accused would have been ineligible for remission of sentence. Have no doubt, the entire operation was choreographed by the Centre in a well-coordinated ‘jugalbandi’! 

Symbols are a microcosmic simulacrum of a country’s history, culture and worldview. A devastating example of symbolism heralding the consecration of the Hindu Rashtra was the recent effacement of the Mahatma’s image from a flyover located right in front of Ahmedabad’s Gujarat Vidyapith university which he had established, and its replacement with Veer Savarkar’s portrait. In the new saffron-tainted India, the icon of secular humanism has been supplanted by the patron saint of Hindutva. It was no surprise that at the over-the-top victory celebrations in Delhi, and the swearing-in of the new government in Gujarat, the presence of a clutch of holy men in saffron robes on the dais was emphatic assertion that religion would be commandeered to gain temporal power and that the religious identity of the majority community is what matters in today’s India.

We seem to have lost the power of compassion and common humanity. The aspirational India envisioned in that magnificent poem, “Let My Country Awake” by Rabindranath Tagore lies in tatters. Written before Independence, it is an inspiring manifesto of hope for every Indian, brimming with optimism at the the sheer promise and possibilities for the future. The poem is also a universal declaration of camaraderie “where the world has not been broken up into fragments by narrow domestic walls….” 

Our present state is a grim contradiction of what our greatest bard envisaged, hence this dire parody (with apologies to Gurudev):

“Where the mind cringes in fear and the head is bent low;
Where knowledge is powerless.
Where the world lies in broken fragments wrecked by the canker of hate.
Where words spring from the depths of chicanery.
Where unrelenting strife reaches out to perdition.
Where the murky stream of vicious unreason has become an ugly habit.
Where the mind is constricted by bigoted thought and action.
From this hell of iniquity, my father, let my country awake!”
At this benighted, hopeless time, if there ever was a bootless cry, the concluding line is it!

(The writer is a former civil servant. Views are personal)

Recent Posts

By choosing the name Leo XIV, the new Pope signals a commitment to justice, humility, and modern relevance—echoing Leo XIII's legacy of defending workers' rights and embracing science, while addressin
apicture A. J. Philip
12 May 2025
India's development dream demands more than GDP growth—social equity, peace, and inclusive governance. Rising communal polarisation, divisive laws, and political exploitation of religious identity thr
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
12 May 2025
"The Earth is a very small stage in a vast, cosmic arena. Think of the rivers of blood spilt by all those generals and emperors so that in glory and triumph they can become momentary masters of a frac
apicture M L Satyan
12 May 2025
In Pahalgam, the terrorists intentionally asked the names of the victims before firing them because they wanted to create a feeling in the minds of Indians that the Muslims killed the Hindus, and that
apicture Jijo Thomas Placheril
12 May 2025
Despite long opposing caste census as divisive, the BJP has now embraced it, likely for electoral gain. Rooted in upper-caste ideology, the RSS-BJP's caste politics have historically undermined social
apicture Ram Puniyani
12 May 2025
Moral ambition urges people to reject hollow careers and pursue meaningful change. Rutger Bregman critiques societal conformity, wasted talent, inequality, and environmental harm, advocating for purpo
apicture G Ramachandram
12 May 2025
The bulldozer, once a tool of construction, now symbolises state-sponsored intimidation—used to demolish homes, silence dissent, and marginalise minorities. Justice demands more than compensation; it
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
12 May 2025
If the drums must beat, let it be for celebration, not conflict. For parades, not pyres. For a country that chooses peace not because it is weak, but because it is strong enough to want no more widows
apicture Robert Clements
12 May 2025
She lost her husband in the attack, yet said she gained two Kashmiri brothers—an almost unbelievable testament to humanity rising above terror, even as the absence of security exposed the failure that
apicture A. J. Philip
05 May 2025
Amid grief, Kashmiris condemned terror and offered aid, while media and political voices stoked communal hatred. True patriotism lies in unity, accountability, and empathy—the values that can heal Ind
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 May 2025