hidden image

Trapping India in a Chakravyuh

G Ramachandram G Ramachandram
05 Aug 2024

Participating in a debate on the Union Budget on July 29, 2024, Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in Lok Sabha (Lower House of the Indian Parliament), in an aggressive, combative speech – his second as the LoP - made a scathing attack on the Budget and the Modi government's insensitivity to the sufferings of the people. It was an extraordinary speech of high intellect for a politician, punctuated with wit and humour, that left the Treasury Benches nervous and anxious, with several acrimonious exchanges between the Treasury and Opposition Benches.

He said: "Fear has pervaded every aspect of our country. Why is this fear spreading so deeply? Thousands of years ago in Haryana in Kurukshetra, Abhimanyu was trapped in a Chakravyuh (the multi-tiered circular formation in the epic Mahabharat in which the enemy was trapped) by six persons and killed. There is fear, and violence in Chakravyuh. Abhimanyu was killed in the Chakravyuh by six persons – Dronacharya, Karna, Kripacharya, Kritavarma, Ashwathama and Shakuni. In the 21st century, a new Chakravyuh is formed in India. Today's Chakravyuh is also controlled by six people: Narendra Modi, Amit Shah, Mohan Bhagwat, Ajit Doval, Gautam Adani, and Mukesh Ambani. What happened to Abhimanyu in the Chakravyuh is happening to our farmers, youth, women and medium and small businesses. There are three forces behind it: first the monopoly capital - financial power – that only two people should be allowed to own the entire wealth of India. Second the misuse of institutions and agencies like the CBI, ED and IT Department and the third the Political Executive. These three together are at the heart of the Chakravyuh, and they have devasted this country. There is nothing in the Budget to break this Chakravyuh. The sole aim of the Budget is to strengthen this framework and the deep State."

The parallel between the Chakravyuh of Mahabharat and that of present-day India is very striking. The present 'Lotus' shaped Chakravyuh is similar to that of the Chakravyuh that killed Abhimanyu. Rahul Gandhi said the Modi government has trapped the youth in a chakravyuh of unemployment and paper leaks, farmers in a chakravyuh of debt, the middle class in a chakravyuh of taxes, MSMEs in a chakravyuh of tax terrorism, jawans in a chakravyuh of Agnipath, and SCs, STs, OBCs and minorities in a chakravyuh of exploitation and injustice: "We break chakravyuhs - independence, Constitution, Green Revolution, MGNREGS are examples. You should not mistake India's youth for Abhimanyu. They are Arjun and will break free from this chakravyuh. You create chakravyuhs, and we break them." He said the INDIA bloc would break this Chakravyuh by carrying out the caste census and legally guaranteeing MSP for farmers. Rahul Gandhi insists on a caste census because it would enable the State to identify the extent of poverty and backwardness among various communities and then distribute the benefits of the State accordingly to ensure justice. It will present each demograhic's social, educational and economic profile to help formulate welfare schemes' policy.

He said that every religion has a formation like chakravyuh for misdeeds. "In Hinduism, 'Shiv ki Baaraat' is the opposite of chakravyuh. Anyone can join 'Shiv ki Baaraat', anyone from any faith. This fight is between 'Shiv ki Baaraat' and Chakravyuh. He made a distinction between Hinduism and Hindutva and asserted that the people in the Treasury Benches who claim to be Hindus do not understand Hinduism.

Throughout Rahul Gandhi's speech, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman was smiling with inappropriate gestures, as if what the LoP was saying made no sense, unable to comprehend the analogy and the seriousness of the issues raised, displaying contempt and a degree of arrogance and insensitivity. This is reflected in her reply to the budget debate the next day. Her reply was more about the whataboutery of the past governments rather than answering the specific issues. She quoted a lot of figures to demonstrate that the Modi government during the past ten years did far better in all aspects than the previous Congress and the UPA governments. The figures quoted by her are questionable and need authentication. She reversed the table against the opposition and accused them of carrying a conspiracy against the Modi government: "Today, India's social fabric, parliamentary traditions, economy are severely attacked." Well, nothing could be further from the truth, as the people understand the reality is the other way round.

Anurag Thakur – former Minister in the Modi government known for his infamous remarks' goli maaro saalon ko' against the people protesting against the Citizens (Amendment) Act (CAA) 2019 in Delhi – responding to the Budget debate had abused Rahul Gandhi: "Jiski jaat ka pata nahin, woh ganana ki baat karta hai" (The person whose caste is not known talks about census). It is an outright insult to the LoP that demonstrates a lack of civility. When Akhilesh Yadav questioned how anyone could ask about a person's caste in the House, Jagadambika Pal, who was chairing the proceedings, said nobody should ask about anyone's caste in the House and that he would expunge the remark. And yet, it is quite demeaning and shocking that Narendra Modi, instead of rebuking Anurag Thakur, was quick to applaud him: "This speech by my young and energetic colleague Anurag Thakur is a must hear. A perfect mix of facts and humour, exposing the dirty politics of the INDI Alliance". This is how he has been vitiating the atmosphere himself by promoting and encouraging a toxic, poisonous narrative to capture power and remain in power. This itself is an example of how India is entrapped in the Chakravyuh of the Modi government.

Rahul Gandhi has emerged as a confident Opposition Leader, articulating and communicating his views very effectively. As Shashi Tharoor says, "He is more accessible to everyone. He is also hands-on as the LoP. The body language and the way he is functioning are conveying very strongly within the party, to allies, and to the BJP that he is in charge and willing to take them (BJP) on."
 

Recent Posts

By choosing the name Leo XIV, the new Pope signals a commitment to justice, humility, and modern relevance—echoing Leo XIII's legacy of defending workers' rights and embracing science, while addressin
apicture A. J. Philip
12 May 2025
India's development dream demands more than GDP growth—social equity, peace, and inclusive governance. Rising communal polarisation, divisive laws, and political exploitation of religious identity thr
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
12 May 2025
"The Earth is a very small stage in a vast, cosmic arena. Think of the rivers of blood spilt by all those generals and emperors so that in glory and triumph they can become momentary masters of a frac
apicture M L Satyan
12 May 2025
In Pahalgam, the terrorists intentionally asked the names of the victims before firing them because they wanted to create a feeling in the minds of Indians that the Muslims killed the Hindus, and that
apicture Jijo Thomas Placheril
12 May 2025
Despite long opposing caste census as divisive, the BJP has now embraced it, likely for electoral gain. Rooted in upper-caste ideology, the RSS-BJP's caste politics have historically undermined social
apicture Ram Puniyani
12 May 2025
Moral ambition urges people to reject hollow careers and pursue meaningful change. Rutger Bregman critiques societal conformity, wasted talent, inequality, and environmental harm, advocating for purpo
apicture G Ramachandram
12 May 2025
The bulldozer, once a tool of construction, now symbolises state-sponsored intimidation—used to demolish homes, silence dissent, and marginalise minorities. Justice demands more than compensation; it
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
12 May 2025
If the drums must beat, let it be for celebration, not conflict. For parades, not pyres. For a country that chooses peace not because it is weak, but because it is strong enough to want no more widows
apicture Robert Clements
12 May 2025
She lost her husband in the attack, yet said she gained two Kashmiri brothers—an almost unbelievable testament to humanity rising above terror, even as the absence of security exposed the failure that
apicture A. J. Philip
05 May 2025
Amid grief, Kashmiris condemned terror and offered aid, while media and political voices stoked communal hatred. True patriotism lies in unity, accountability, and empathy—the values that can heal Ind
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 May 2025