hidden image

Weaponising Tax Law to Suppress Freedom of the Press

Joseph Maliakan Joseph Maliakan
17 Mar 2025

Though the Supreme Court of India and several High Courts have repeatedly held that freedom of expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution is a fundamental right and cannot be suppressed, the Income Tax Department of the Union government disagrees.

In Romesh Thapar vs. State of Madras (1950), the Supreme Court ruled that the press plays a significant role in informing the public and promoting democratic values. Therefore, any attempt to curtail the freedom of the press would violate the right to freedom of expression.

However, asserting that "journalism does not serve any public purpose," the Income Tax authorities on January 27, 2025, refused to extend the philanthropic status to The Reporters' Collective, an association of journalists that has consistently published reports critical of the Union government headed by Narendra Modi.

A recent report titled "Inside Modi Govt's War Room to Whitewash Global Indices" revealed that the Modi government had been lobbying to change methodologies to boost India's ranking in global indices.

The Reporters' Collective has been operating in India as a registered non-profit organisation since July 2021. The revocation of the non-profit status means that the group will no longer be exempt from paying income tax. The group will have to pay tax on all donations it receives. Donors to the group will also not be entitled to a tax rebate because the group will be treated as a commercial organisation.

Donations received by organisations registered under section 12 AB of the Income Tax Act are not taken as normal taxable income, and the amount given by donors also gets an exemption in income tax. Now that the IT department has cancelled the Repoters' Collective's non-profit status, not only future donations but also past donations can be taxed.

Under section 115TD, accumulations an institution made before the cancellation can also be taxed. When registration as a non-profit is cancelled, tax at the maximum marginal rate, which can vary between 30 and 42 per cent, depending on the income, will be levied.

In January 2024, the TRC reported that in 2014, Prime Minister Narendra Modi had tried to hold "backdoor negotiations with the Finance Commission to cut tax funds allocated to the states." The TRC also reported on women's safety, environmental issues, and the ethnic conflict in Manipur. It also carried investigative reports on the Union Government's Electoral Bonds Scheme and on the murky business operations of the Adani group.

Several opposition leaders have condemned the misuse of the IT department to suppress criticism of the government. Congress leader P Chidambaram tweeted, "One more building block of freedom was knocked down when the Income Tax Department cancelled non-profit status of The Reporters' Collective." Congress MP Randeep Singh Surjewala tweeted, "the facist Modi government is inimical to independent media and hates free press. The pliant, subservient media of today is a poor commentary on the brick by brick designed obliteration of democracy." Former TMC MP Jawhar Sircar said the Prime Minister "unleashed Income Tax hounds to terrorise the media that exposes his corruption and highhandedness."

In June 2024, the IT department cancelled the tax exemption status of Aman Biradari, an NGO headed by human rights activist Harsh Mander, and its registration under section 12 AB of the Income Tax Act 1961.

Section 2(15) of the Income Tax Act defines "charitable purpose" as including "relief of the poor, education, yoga, medical relief, preservation of environment and preservation of monuments or places or objects of artistic or historic interest and advancement of any other object of general public utility."

Seven kinds of activity are considered charitable for tax exemption. The first six are charitable per se. The seventh residual kind is the advancement of 'any other object of public utility.' The residual category is relevant in The Reporters' Collective case.

The Act does not clarify what constitutes "general public utility." It means that the activity has a worthy purpose and an element of public character and must relate to a sufficiently large section of the public. Examining the objectives with which a trust or institution has been set up is the starting point for deciding whether it has a charitable purpose.

Are the activities to be carried out on a non-profit, no-loss basis? Do the activities have a worthy purpose? Will the activities benefit the public at large? If the answers are in the affirmative, the activities should be considered to be of general public utility.

The TRC's main objectives are education and other objects of general public utility. Other objectives would be to publish news, conduct research, promote journalism, and conduct training and educational activities. These are non-profitable activities since they are conducted on a non-profit, no-loss basis.

Public utility is implicit in philanthro-journalism. The primary role of responsible journalism is to build an informed citizenry and act as a 'watchdog' in a democracy. Responsible journalism must be essentially considered as advancing "general public utility."

However, the Commissioner's order revoking TRC's non-profit status does not record that the association is undertaking commercial activities for consideration. The Commissioner has very casually denied registration by claiming that journalism does not have public utility. This, therefore, is a clear case of arbitrary exercise of power without proper application of mind.

On February 10, the Delhi High Court, hearing a writ petition submitted by the Reporters' Collective challenging the Income Tax Commissioner's order, directed the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal to resolve the issue expeditiously.

Recent Posts

The Supreme Court's landmark ruling against Governor RN Ravi marks a decisive victory for Tamil Nadu. It is the first step towards curbing central overreach and reaffirming state autonomy. This is def
apicture Dr John Singarayar
14 Apr 2025
RN Ravi and Arif Mohammed Khan are emblematic of a broader trend where Governors in Opposition-ruled states obstruct elected governments. The Supreme Court's landmark verdict reasserts constitutional
apicture A. J. Philip
14 Apr 2025
Good Friday challenges the world's selfishness with Jesus' radical love and sacrifice. The Cross and Eucharist call Christians to humble service, justice, and compassion—not rituals alone. True discip
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
14 Apr 2025
Journalist Rupesh Kumar Singh, jailed under the UAPA since July 2022, marks 1000 days in prison. His arrest followed reports exposing industrial pollution harming Adivasi livelihoods. While witnesses
apicture Joseph Maliakan
14 Apr 2025
In a world chasing glory and power, the simple act of "tying a towel" calls us back to humility and service—values Christ exemplified and Mother Teresa embodied. True greatness lies not in dominance b
apicture Peter Fernandes
14 Apr 2025
MA Baby's rise to CPI(M) general secretary has rekindled concerns. His past policies and public remarks raise questions about whether his leadership can truly embrace inclusive, coexistence-based secu
apicture Joe Kavalam
14 Apr 2025
Only those who pass the Laughter Test get a ministry berth. Why? Because if you can't laugh at yourself, you'll never understand the joke, democracy sometimes makes of power.
apicture Robert Clements
14 Apr 2025
Erosion of the rule of law is disturbingly gaining traction in India, marked by mob violence, state complicity, and selective justice. Minority communities face targeted attacks, and dissenters are si
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
07 Apr 2025
IIT and MBA graduates struggle with employment despite premier degrees, often turning to food stalls or gig work. A failing education-employment system, outdated curricula, and rising costs leave many
apicture Jaswant Kaur
07 Apr 2025
Despite being the backbone of Kerala's healthcare system, ASHAs are underpaid, overworked, and denied worker status. Their demands for fair wages and benefits remain unmet while the centre and state g
apicture Joseph Maliakan
07 Apr 2025