hidden image

Wise Becoming Fools

Nikil Robin Nikil Robin
18 Mar 2024

The recent controversy surrounding the names of two lions, Sita and Akbar, at a zoo in Kolkata, has ignited a heated debate about the power of religious beliefs and their impact on society. This incident, which escalated to a plea in the High Court, serves as a stark reminder of the delicate balance between religious sensitivities and secular values in India. The Vishwa Hindu Parishad's petition challenging the names of the lions as "blasphemous" and an "assault on Hindu religious beliefs" is a clear example of how religious sensitivities can lead to irrational and extreme reactions.

The VHP's argument that naming a lioness after Sita, a revered figure in Hindu mythology, alongside a lion named Akbar, a Mughal emperor, violated their right to freedom of religion and equality reflects the deep-seated religious tensions that exist in Indian society. The belief that such a naming choice could cause immense hurt to the Hindu community's religious sentiments shows the extent to which people are willing to go to protect their religious beliefs, even if it means resorting to legal action.

The High Court's observation that the names of the lions could potentially cause controversy and advisory to the West Bengal government to consider renaming them to "avoid controversy" is a troubling indication of how even the judiciary can be swayed by religious sentiments. The court's suggestion that the government should prioritise maintaining peace and harmony over upholding the right to freedom of expression is a worrying sign of the erosion of secular values in India. The eventual outcome of the case, with the Bengal government renaming the lions "Vijay" and "Vijaya" in response to the controversy, highlights the power of religious beliefs to influence decision-making at all levels of society. The fact that a seemingly innocuous naming choice could lead to such a heated debate and ultimately result in a name change is a testament to the hold that religion has over people's minds and actions.

The case of Sita and Akbar and the legal drama are cautionary tales about the dangers of allowing religious beliefs to influence decision-making in a secular society. The fact that a simple naming choice could lead to such a divisive and contentious legal battle is a stark reminder of the need for tolerance, understanding, and respect for diversity. It's concerning to note that blind belief has led even to animals being tied to religious divisions, with attempts to sow seeds of hatred and discrimination even among them. This situation reflects a troubling trend where people struggle to accept names chosen for animals that are completely separate from religious contexts, raising questions about their ability to embrace other religions. Such actions may fuel future rivalries or conflicts among religions. Moreover, it's disheartening to witness the judiciary being influenced by religious beliefs, mirroring the sentiments of those who petitioned. This underscores the need for a more secular approach within the government, ensuring decisions are based on principles of justice and equality rather than religious bias.

Recent Posts

From Somnath to Ayodhya, history is being recast as grievance and revenge as politics. Myths replace evidence, Nehru and Gandhi are caricatured, and ancient plunder is weaponised to divide the present
apicture Ram Puniyani
19 Jan 2026
When leaders invoke "revenge" and ancient wounds, politics turns supposed grievances into fuel. From Somnath to Delhi, history is repurposed to polarise, distract from governance, and normalise hate,
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
19 Jan 2026
As Blackstone and KKR buy Kerala's hospitals, care risks becoming a balance-sheet decision. The state's current people-first model faces an American-style, insurance-driven system where MBAs replace d
apicture Joseph Maliakan
19 Jan 2026
Christians are persecuted in every one of the eight countries in South Asia, but even prominent religious groups, Hindus and Muslims, and smaller groups of Sikhs and Buddhists, also find themselves ta
apicture John Dayal
19 Jan 2026
"The Patronage of 'Daily-ness': Holiness in the Ordinary"
apicture Rev. Dr Merlin Rengith Ambrose, DCL
19 Jan 2026
Pride runs deeper than we often admit. It colours the way we see ourselves, shapes the circles we move in, and decides who gets to stand inside those circles with us. Not all pride works the same way.
apicture Dr John Singarayar
19 Jan 2026
India's problem is no longer judicial overreach but executive overdrive. Through agencies, procedure and timing, politics now shapes legality itself. Courts arrive late, elections are influenced early
apicture Oliver D'Souza
19 Jan 2026
India is being hollowed out twice over: votes bought with stolen welfare money, and voters erased by design. As politics becomes spectacle and bribery becomes policy, democracy slips from "vote chori"
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
19 Jan 2026
Oh my follower, You named yourself mine. To gain convenience Personal, professional, political Without ever touching
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
19 Jan 2026
Our chains are more sophisticated. They are decorated with religion. Polished with patriotism. Justified with fear of 'the other.' We are told someone is always trying to convert us. Someone is always
apicture Robert Clements
19 Jan 2026