Another Commission, for What

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
03 Oct 2022
A 2008 study commissioned by the National Commission for Minorities found that caste divisions exist among Christians and Muslims just as they exist among their counterparts in Hindu, Sikh and Buddhist religions.

Yet another Commission to study the status of the Dalit Christians and Muslims is coming. There is nothing more pretentious than this move. The intent is doubtful as there is no dearth of such Commissions and their reports which are lying in the ‘cold storage’, exposing the government’s apathy. To put the issue in the right perspective, Dalit Christians and Muslims, the victims of a flawed reservation policy, have been clamouring for Scheduled Caste status which is limited to their counterparts among Hindus, Buddhists and Sikhs. Thus, Dalits converted to Christianity and Islam continue to be victims of a religion-based reservation policy, despite ample evidence that they too suffer from social and economic backwardness just as their counterparts who enjoy the benefits of Scheduled Caste status. 

Coming to the Modi government’s reported move to set up a Commission to study the status of Dalit Christians and Muslims, it is nothing but a tactics to bluff them. The government has in its possession reports which suggest that the status of Dalit Muslims and Christians is no different from that of the Dalits of other religious communities for whom SC status has been granted on different occasions. A 2008 study commissioned by the National Commission for Minorities found that caste divisions exist among Christians and Muslims just as they exist among their counterparts in Hindu, Sikh and Buddhist religions. Christianity and Islam – just as Sikhism and Buddhism – do not have explicit caste structure as in Hinduism; but the stigma of caste identity follow them even after their conversion. Though their religious affiliations change, their social status do not alter; their branding as Christians and Muslims of ‘low origin’ continues to stick with them, despite scriptural proscription.

Studies have brought out shocking state of the status of Dalit Christians and Muslims. There are places they have separate mosques and churches and burial grounds; inter-marriages hardly take places; and there is sparse interaction and cooperation. There is perceptible difference in education between Dalits and non-Dalits in both the communities; there is grave economic disparity too. The data gathered by the National Sample Survey Office too give credence to the glaring disparity between the Dalits and non-Dalits among Muslims and Christians. It is to be noted that no government has repudiated these findings. 

It is hypocrisy that a government which is ‘equipped with’ reports containing data and statistics on the status of Dalit Christians and Muslims is considering setting up yet another Commission to study the same issue. It is nothing but a ploy to keep the issue endlessly in the ‘cold storage’. The ‘masters’ behind the BJP regime would certainly not allow the issue to be settled in favour of Dalit Christians and Muslims for obvious reasons. The Dalit Christians and Muslims are not asking for any special favour; they are seeking their right which has been granted to their counterparts in other religions. It is another matter that the government reportedly filed an affidavit a couple of years back in the Supreme Court stating that Dalits who converted to Buddhism could not be compared to those who converted to Islam or Christianity. This indicates what is in store for them irrespective of the findings of the new Commission. 

Dalit Christians Muslims government Scheduled Caste status religion-based reservation policy religious communities National Commission for Minorities mosques church National Sample Survey Office Issue 41 2022 Indian Currents

Recent Posts

Close at the heel of our other neighbours, Nepal's journey has swung between hope and betrayal. The monarchy fell, the republic faltered, and now its youth demand dignity, justice, and a future free f
apicture A. J. Philip
15 Sep 2025
The recent Vice-Presidential election has exposed deep cracks in India's democracy. Cross-voting, intimidation, abstentions, and invalid ballots have raised serious doubts. It ultimately begs the ques
apicture M L Satyan
15 Sep 2025
September 11 carries memories of violence and division, but also of Gandhi's Satyagraha and Vivekananda's call to end fanaticism. In a world scarred by war, injustice, and hate, 9/11 must challenge us
apicture Cedric Prakash
15 Sep 2025
India may soon become the world's third-largest economy, but its low per capita income, unmitigated inequality, weak healthcare, and fragile education system reveal a different truth. GDP milestones a
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
15 Sep 2025
Modi's long-delayed visit to Manipur are mere optics. After two years of silence amid ethnic cleansing, displacement, and inhumanity by the Meiteis, what peace, protection of minorities, and restorati
apicture Dr Manoj Kumar Mishra
15 Sep 2025
Umar Khalid, the Jawaharlal Nehru University scholar who has spent more than five years in jail, on Thursday, September 11, told a Delhi court that the larger Conspiracy case in connection with the 20
apicture Joseph Maliakan
15 Sep 2025
Looking back at the 100 years of Medical Mission Sisters, there was a pioneering spirit to begin health care facilities for the less privileged, openness to look at themselves critically to make their
apicture Sr. Mary Pullattu, MMS
15 Sep 2025
Though declared a secular republic in 2008, the nation's legal and cultural frameworks remain steeped in Hindu-majority sentiment. Nepal's National Penal Code of 2017 criminalises religious conversion
apicture CM Paul
15 Sep 2025
To be a "Carmelite on the street" is to unite deep prayer with public courage. We must build interior castles yet opening their gates, carrying contemplation into classrooms, farms, protests, and parl
apicture Gisel Erumachadathu, ASI
15 Sep 2025
In today's India, more than flyovers or metros, what we desperately need are bridges. Bridges between communities. Bridges between faiths. Bridges strong enough to carry us into the future without col
apicture Robert Clements
15 Sep 2025