Bench, Bent, and Broken: India's Judicial Crisis

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
16 Dec 2024

Many must have watched videos of non-Indians praising the Indian culture, education, ideology, religions, etc., and felt emotional and proud to be Indians. However, how many have realised that these are paid shenanigans? While the West is moving towards wokeness, India is moving towards the other end, which, for the lack of a better coinage, I must represent as somewhere between malevolent patsyness or pernicious naivety and self-serving credulity. These are not opposed to each other; both are jaundiced towards extreme inanity.

A judge making a statement that degrades a section of society in complete disregard to the Constitution and agreement with anarchy is unforgivable. Though vociferations have risen from various quarters calling for an impeachment, I posit that this is not the point at which he should have been tackled. It is not the first time that Mr Shekhar Kumar Yadav, I'll let his honour qualify the title Hon'ble, has been found with his pants down.

Justice, he may or may not be, but he has the honour of a long appendage of unjustified and unjustifiable behaviours in his name. Sidestepping even his nefarious parts, how was he allowed to continue as a judge, that too of a high court, when he is so daft as to believe that bovines exhale oxygen? His qualifications should immediately have been brought to review, and he should have been dismissed summarily and all his judgements scrutinised. That such criminality as his appointment occurred speaks volumes about the current state of our judiciary.

It is incontrovertible that he will not have to suffer any severe consequences as the whole bastion of the judiciary has already been infiltrated. At most, he might have to wave his gown goodbye and take up his seat in the political arena a bit ahead of time. The million-dollar question that few have alluded to is whether his willingness to strip publicly has any deeper implications. And even more concerning is that the majority is apathetic or jubilant. It is scary to think where we might be heading.

The deeper malaise lies not just in this judge's aberrant statements but in the systemic breakdown that allows such individuals to ascend to positions of judicial authority. It represents a larger pattern of intellectual capitulation, where pseudo-scientific claims are elevated, and constitutional values are trampled under the hooves of majoritarian sentiment.

Judges are not merely interpreters of the law but custodians of societal values. When they begin to articulate views at odds with constitutional principles, they allow cracks that fragment the very foundation of our country. It is no longer about impeaching one judge but addressing the rot that allows such appointments. It demands a comprehensive review of judicial selection processes, a rigorous mechanism of accountability, and, most importantly, a societal commitment to upholding constitutional values.

Recent Posts

A democracy must distinguish between an armed insurgent and a questioning citizen. Calling critics, students, academics or activists "Dimaagi Naxals" is unacceptable. Strength lies not in silencing di
apicture Dr Martin Valiyaparambil VC
24 Aug 2026
As I watched, I could not help remembering the interview I did with your father, NKP Salve, for Jain TV in the 1990s. Goswami, I presume, was then still "studying for some time in a Jesuit-run school,
apicture A. J. Philip
24 Aug 2026
After years in abeyance, Justice Sunday returns at a moment of profound national crisis. From poverty and exclusion to attacks on minorities and environmental destruction, the Church is called to recl
apicture Cedric Prakash
24 Aug 2026
Israel has transformed from the biblical David into a heavily armed Goliath. Self-defence cannot justify occupation, mass displacement and civilian suffering. The world must find the courage to act.
apicture P. A. Chacko
24 Aug 2026
Pellet guns were fired at protesting students, and nobody can say who ordered it. The issue has transcended one incident. Power remains concentrated, but responsibility is endlessly dispersed.
apicture Oliver D'Souza
24 Aug 2026
Beneath India's boasts of growth and power, a deeper restlessness is spreading. Jobs vanish, institutions weaken, citizens move, dissent is silenced, and trust collapses; the CJP's rise reflects this
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
24 Aug 2026
Sanatan borders bruised me In caste societies. Left Ideologies crushed me In European societies. Sharia societies Erased my skin.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
24 Aug 2026
Unity is beautiful, but only when united around what is right. Otherwise, unity merely allows everyone to become lost without feeling lonely.
apicture Robert Clements
24 Aug 2026
Bengal once welcomed missionaries who built schools, hospitals and presses, enriching the region's education, healthcare and reform. Today, priests are told to leave their parishes. The irony is devas
apicture CM Paul
17 Aug 2026
With Christians constituting barely 2.3 per cent of India's population, the charge of mass forced conversion defies logic. Yet anti-conversion laws pivot charity into "allurement," suspicion and crime
apicture Chhotebhai
17 Aug 2026