Death Knell of Secularism

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
25 Jul 2022
Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently unveiled the Ashoka Pillar, the national emblem, on the top of the upcoming building, and he performed a puja according to Hindu rituals and prayers.

The country is set to get a new Parliament building to ‘house’ the sanctum sanctorum of democracy. Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently unveiled the Ashoka Pillar, the national emblem, on the top of the upcoming building, and he performed a puja according to Hindu rituals and prayers. Leaders, cutting across party lines, made disparaging remarks over conducting a religious ceremony of one faith when the Constitution of India stipulates that the State does not profess or practice any religion. Moreover, the Hindu rituals were held at a place which is to uphold the Constitution, the preamble of which proclaims India as a secular state.

Cut to a similar incident down South in Tamil Nadu. A DMK MP who had gone to attend Bhoomi puja marking the restoration work of a lake in his constituency blurted out at the government officials for conducting prayers and rituals of only Hindu religion. He blasted the officials for ignoring other religions and their leaders at a government function which is meant for all irrespective of religious affinities and affiliations. In a related development, Dravidar Munnetra Kazhagam has asked Tamil Nadu Chief Minister to do away with religious ceremonies and rituals performed by priests in government functions. As the government belongs to all those who believed in different religions -- even atheists and agnostics -- avoiding rituals and religious ceremonies would protect the constitutional norms. Political probity demands that the State cannot differentiate between religions; it cannot treat one religion with special indulgence and ignore the others.

The puja at the installation of the national emblem is incongruous with the national ethos and constitutional propriety. It is unconstitutional to favour one religion, disregarding the others. The function of installing the 9500-kg Ashoka Pillar with rituals of the majority religion weighs down heavily on the secular tenets of the Constitution. Separation of religion from State and its functions is fundamental to a secular nation. The soul of secularism cannot be stained by rituals of a particular religion. The corner stone of secularism is State’s disengagement with religion.

The best example for separation of religion from the State and the Government came from Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru who expressed his displeasure over then President Dr. Rajendra Prasad’s decision to inaugurate the refurbished Somnath Temple. Nehru’s contention was that in a secular state, it is not advisable for the State personnel (in this case the head of the State) to get engaged in public activities related to any religion. It is this vision of Nehru on which a secular state should be built. If top constitutional and government functionaries get involved in rituals, pujas and prayers of any particular religion, it would sound the death knell of secularism.

India is not a theocratic state, unlike its neighbour Pakistan, but a secular one which gives every religion the right to be treated equally. The government that focuses on refurbishing and renovating religious places at the expense of public exchequer would do well to remember the stand Nehru took on the issue. It is tantamount to giving pride of place to the majority religion to the exclusion of others. Modi performing puja at the foundation laying ceremony of the grand temple at Ayodhya and during the unveiling of the national emblem atop Parliament building is diametrically opposed to secularism as enumerated in the Constitution. The government is ostensibly making the road to Hindu Rashtra wider and smoother.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi Ashok Stambh Constitution of India Religious ceremonies Secularism Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru Hindu Rashtra Issue 31 2022 Indian Currents Indian Currents Magazine

Recent Posts

Courts speak through evidence, not the religion of judges or the accused. Once judicial decisions are judged by identity instead of reasoning, the blindfold of Lady Justice falls, and with it, public
apicture A. J. Philip
13 Jul 2026
Religion loses its soul when it becomes a vehicle for power and profit. The Ayodhya donation controversy exposes how faith is exploited for political capital and commercial enterprise. Democracy deman
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
13 Jul 2026
The deadliest weapon in modern India is invisible. Armed only with smartphones, artificial intelligence, and psychological manipulation, cybercriminals are stealing fortunes, destroying reputations, a
apicture Jaswant Kaur
13 Jul 2026
The One Nation, One Election Bill might promise slightly more efficiency, but it will damage the constitutional foundations of India's democracy. Administrative convenience cannot justify concentratin
apicture Joseph Maliakan
13 Jul 2026
When every constitutional safeguard appears compromised, the judiciary becomes democracy's last refuge. Though there have been some recent judicial interventions, they are only on the fringes and quic
apicture G Ramachandram
13 Jul 2026
Mumbai is India's financial hub. With an estimated population of 12.5 million, it is home to more billionaires than any other city in Asia. This city is renowned for its Bollywood movies, ambitious sp
apicture Fr. Anil Prakash D'Souza, OP
13 Jul 2026
A night that starts Whenever a non-Dalit Picks up a weapon Because someone Of "his" caste Was insulted By the sight Of a Mlechchha standing tall.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
13 Jul 2026
Democracy was never meant to end on polling day. It was meant to continue every day thereafter, with governments being questioned, ministers being challenged, and officials knowing that somebody, some
apicture Robert Clements
13 Jul 2026
Fifty years after the Emergency, the debate has shifted from suspended Democracy to whether democratic institutions can be hollowed out while elections continue and constitutional forms remain outward
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
06 Jul 2026
Is India moving forward or slipping backwards? Growing concerns over democratic institutions, civil liberties, economic inequality, and constitutional values have kept the national debate over whether
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
06 Jul 2026