Dichotomy of a Summit

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
18 Sep 2023

Going by the achievements and appreciatory words of the world leaders, the G20 summit held in New Delhi from September 9 to 10 has proved the prowess of the country. The adoption of the New Delhi Declaration, especially as it was seen as a difficult proposition considering the diverging views on Ukraine war, was nothing less than pulling off a coup by the Indian negotiators. India’s presidency of the G20 was also marked by the novel way of holding 200 meetings in over 60 cities. The inclusion of the African Union as the 21st member of the organization and the decision to establish the India-Middle East-Europe Corridor are other major developments at the two-day mega event. 

However, the pomp and show that marked the event and the speeches of Prime Minister Narendra Modi have another story to tell. One cannot ignore the demolitions of slums as part of the beautification of Delhi that put the poor and the marginalized people to untold troubles and travails. This led to displacement of a large number of the poor forcing them to lose their daily earnings. Equally disgraceful was the method used to hide the city’s slums behind large green curtains and similar cover-up operations. Foreign media went to the town with elaborate reportage on such ignominious steps by the government.

The Prime Minister used the occasion to preach about the significance of democracy, diversity, human-centric approach, larger role for women in leadership and decision-making, respect to all religions, and such values. Ironically, the ground reality in India is miles away from the ideals lectured by him. “As the Mother of Democracy, our belief in dialogue and democratic principles has been unwavering since time immemorial,” he said at the inauguration of the Summit. 

Contrast it with the number of state governments in the country that fell like house of cards to give way to regimes run by the BJP; the numerous elected representatives who switched sides to enable the saffron party to come to power; and the list of parties that split like amoeba to help BJP form governments. Is it the ‘mother of democracy’ that Modi talked about? It is not without reason that India is described as ‘electoral autocracy’ by a reputed research group.

Modi spoke about dialogue as the bedrock of democracy. Even before the ink that reported his speech dried up, a five-day special session of the Parliament was announced, taking the opposition parties by surprise, without even specifying what for it was called. 

He characterised India as land of diversity of faith, adding that every religion of the world has found respect here. Juxtapose this with the fate of the minority communities in the country; the innumerable attacks on them and their worshiping places; the lynching of minorities by cow vigilantes; and the fact that India stands somewhere at the bottom of the freedom of religion index. 

The Prime Minister talked about women empowerment that will be a significant driver of change in the 21st century. It is still fresh in the memory Indians how women sports icons spent days and nights on the road in the heart of Delhi seeking justice for several of their ilk who had been allegedly molested by a prominent law-maker of Modi’s party. They are still waiting for the eluding justice. This much for the ruling party’s love and respect for women. Hence, unless the two sides of the G 20 story are written with equal prominence, it will remain incomplete for the generations to come.  

Recent Posts

The Emergency must be remembered, not as a tool to target a political party but as a lesson against authoritarian excess. Yet, we cannot ignore that worse violations of democratic norms and human righ
apicture A. J. Philip
30 Jun 2025
Fifty years later, India faces a chilling déjà vu with an 'undeclared' Emergency. Freedom of speech is stifled, dissent is suppressed, and institutions are compromised. True democracy demands resistan
apicture Cedric Prakash
30 Jun 2025
Amit Shah's claim that those who speak English will be ashamed evidences that the BJP-RSS is trying to bring down the populace and push India into another Vedic dark age where ignorance and superstiti
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
30 Jun 2025
The NSE's ?1,400 crore settlement with SEBI raises critical concerns about India's financial markets. Any perceived regulatory capture risks eroding trust.
apicture Jaswant Kaur
30 Jun 2025
Christian education in India has had a profound influence on democracy and social justice in the country. It played a pivotal role in challenging caste oppression, promoting inclusivity, and fostering
apicture Fr Soroj Mullick, SDB
30 Jun 2025
"The spread of digital culture, particularly evident among young people, is profoundly changing their experience of space and time; it influences their daily activities, communication, and interperson
apicture Joe Eruppakkatt
30 Jun 2025
Welcome to the Happy State of Emergency: Where freedom is carefully curated, minds are pre-cooked, and Big Brother doesn't need to frown—he just raises one eyebrow... and we salute…!
apicture Robert Clements
30 Jun 2025
The North-South divide reflects India's broader regional and cultural tensions. The progress of Southern states in health, education, and development contrasts with the Hindi belt's struggles on devel
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
23 Jun 2025
India's 2027 census and ensuing delimitation will redefine its political landscape. As northern states gain influence due to burgeoning population, southern states will face reduced representation des
apicture Dr John Singarayar
23 Jun 2025
For India to become a global healthcare power, it must democratise medical education—revise outdated rules, invest in public institutions, expand seats, embrace technology, and ensure affordability. A
apicture A. J. Philip
23 Jun 2025