Relief, At What Cost?

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
19 Sep 2022
At last bail has been granted to Siddique Kappan and Teesta Setalvad. Kappan was in jail for nearly two years; Teesta for over two months.

At last bail has been granted to Siddique Kappan and Teesta Setalvad. Kappan was in jail for nearly two years; Teesta for over two months. Though Teesta walked out of the imposing gates of an Ahmedabad jail, Kappan has not been fortunate enough to do so as an Enforcement Directorate case is pending against him. 

The news of bail soothes the ears and comforts the hearts of those who have been agitated over the vindictiveness of the government against the two -- one a rights activist and the other a journalist. However, crucial questions beg to be answered as their arrests, and prolonged incarceration, have wider implications. 

The Supreme Court’s observation that every citizen has the right to free expression is a slap on the Uttar Pradesh police which arrested the journalist who was on his way to Hathras to report on the gang-rape and murder of a Dalit girl there. He was charged under the stringent Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) accusing him of inciting violence. 

The malicious mind of the government and its police was exposed when the court told on the face of the prosecution that it has not shown anything against Kappan that was provocative. Similarly, Teesta, who was charged with forgery and criminal conspiracy related to 2002 Gujarat riots, was granted interim bail on four grounds. 

The arrest and imprisonment of Kappan and Teesta bare the malevolent and mala fide intentions of the government and its agencies to foist rigorous sections of UAPA on those who are perceived to be dissenters and working against the powers-that-be. The bail and the Court’s observations are a rap on the knuckles of the law-enforcing agencies who are apparently working at the behest of their masters; it is a signal to the prosecuting agencies that imprisoning people for long duration without bail is against the spirit of the law. It also speaks poorly on the judiciary that it took two years for Kappan to get bail though the prosecution could not provide any substantial evidence against him. The same is true for Teesta too.

The oral observation of the Court, as to how possession of pamphlets could be construed as one’s involvement in violence or incitement to violence, has far-reaching impact on the pending cases in which scores of people are languishing in jail, without bail, for years together.

In the case of late Stan Swamy, or others who are in jail, in connection with the Bhima-Koregaon case, the investigating agencies have shown possession of leaflets and letters as ‘clinching’ evidence against the accused. Intriguingly, in some cases, it has come to light that the agencies had surreptitiously planted those evidences on the computers of the accused. 

The relief to Kappan and Teesta, though came belatedly, could become a precedent in cases in which people are jailed on ‘trumped up’ charges. It is a message to the judiciary at all levels that people should not be allowed to be persecuted, disallowing them bail. It is pertinent to listen to what Justice H. R Khanna, in a dissenting judgment, wrote, many years ago: “The rule of law is the accepted norm in all civilised societies. Everywhere it is identified with the liberty of the individual. It seeks to maintain a balance between the opposing notions of Individual Liberty and Public Order.”

Siddique Kappan Teesta Setalvad rights activist journalist Supreme Court right to free expression Uttar Pradesh police Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act 2002 Gujarat riots Stan Swamy Bhima-Koregaon case rule of law Individual Liberty Public Order Issue 39 2022 Indian Currents

Recent Posts

Release of eight Cheetahs, brought from Namibia, by Prime Minister Narendra Modi on his 72nd birthday on 17th September
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
26 Sep 2022
The Indian National Congress (INC) was founded by Allan Octavian Hume, a British civil servant.
apicture A. J. Philip
26 Sep 2022
The allegation that Jawaharlal Nehru did nothing to keep alive the memory of Subhash Chandra Bose is false to the core
apicture Ram Puniyani
26 Sep 2022
Horse-trading involving MLAs has become the biggest threat to the functioning of democratic governments
apicture M L Satyan
26 Sep 2022
Turncoats are common in Indian politics. But what happened in Goa takes the cake. A senior Congress leader recently claimed that he switched sides after permission from God
apicture Pachu Menon
26 Sep 2022
Fifty years is a unique occasion to rejoice and thank God for what Federation Asian Bishops’ Conference (FABC) has achieved with God's grace
apicture Felix Wilfred
26 Sep 2022
There is an urgent need to rein in recovery agents, outsourced by financial companies, who act ruthlessly, leading to many untoward instances
apicture Aarti
26 Sep 2022
With all the skirmishes going on between the governors of the different states, especially those ruled by the opposition and the elected representatives
apicture Robert Clements
26 Sep 2022
Two high-profile pleas for bail came up for hearing recently in the Supreme Court: one was from Teesta Setalvad and the other from Siddique Kappan.
apicture Cedric Prakash
19 Sep 2022
A relative was granted unconditional bail by the CBI judge on the first day the case came up before her. The case was that he “received” two Rs 500 notes as bribe.
apicture A. J. Philip
19 Sep 2022