Reservation Sans Entry

Dr Suresh Mathew Dr Suresh Mathew
25 Sep 2023

Their seats are reserved. But, they have neither got the tickets nor they are aware of the timing of the journey. They are in the dark, holding on to the hope given to them -- one day they will be able to travel, using the reservation made in their name. Yes, that is the fate of the Women’s Reservation Bill, titled Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam 2023, passed by the two Houses of Parliament. It is historic, no doubt, as it is the culmination of many twists and turns in the making of the Bill that affects more than half the population of the country.  

The Women’s Reservation Bill was brought to Parliament several times, starting from 1996. It was again and again tabled in the House, with no success. In 2010, during the UPA government under Manmohan Singh, the Bill crossed one hurdle when it was passed in Rajya Sabha, but not lucky in Lok Sabha. Now, after 13 years, it has been passed by Parliament, with near unanimity. It provides for 33 per cent (or one-third) seats for women in Lok Sabha and state Assemblies; it also provides similar reservation for women in SC, ST category. Another significant provision is that the seats reserved for women will be rotated after every delimitation exercise, presumably  every 10 years.

So far so good. The representation of women at present in Parliament and state legislatures is less than 15 percent whereas at the global level women’s representation in the legislative bodies is around 24%. In Scandinavian countries, it goes up to 45 per cent while in some of the European countries it is between 30 and 35 per cent. Hence, India will be in the group of some of the European nations after the Bill becomes an Act and is implemented. It could become a watershed in the democratic journey of India.

Now comes the flip side. Despite marathon discussion in both Houses of Parliament in the run-up to the passing of the Bill, none from the government side could come up with a date when the provisions of the Bill would be implemented. The only assurance is that it would be implemented once the Census and the subsequent delimitation of constituencies are completed. Here again there is a trap. The government has not announced any date for the completion of the Census; hence there is no clarity as to when the delimitation will take place. But going by the previous delimitation which took place in 1976 based on the 1971 census, it took more than four years to complete the process. It is not clear how long women will have to wait counting down the days for the fulfillment of their dream. 

Hence, one is at a loss to understand the hurry with which a special session of Parliament was convened, with the agenda shrouded in secrecy. If the provisions of the Bill are not to be implemented in the near future, it could have been passed in the coming Winter Session. It would not be wrong to say that there is more to it than meet the eyes. Women’s empowerment can happen only if the government shows political will to implement the provisions of the Bill immediately. If its intention is to open up more space for women in the political arena, it should brook no delay in implementing it.  
 

Recent Posts

Communal hatred, seeded by colonial divide-and-rule and revived by modern majoritarianism, is corroding India's syncretic culture. Yet acts of everyday courage remind us that constitutional values and
apicture Ram Puniyani
16 Feb 2026
What appears as cultural homage is, in fact, political signalling. By elevating Vande Mataram symbolism over inclusion, the state is diminishing the national anthem, unsettling hard-won consensus, and
apicture A. J. Philip
16 Feb 2026
States are increasingly becoming laboratories of hate; the experiment will ultimately consume the nation itself. The choice before India is stark: reaffirm constitutional citizenship, or allow adminis
apicture John Dayal
16 Feb 2026
Mamata Banerjee's personal appearance before the Supreme Court of India has transformed a procedural dispute over SIR into a constitutional warning—questioning whether institutions meant to safeguard
apicture Oliver D'Souza
16 Feb 2026
This is a book by two redoubtable Jesuit scholars. Lancy Lobo is currently the Research Director of the Indian Social Institute in New Delhi, while Denzil Fernandes was its former Executive Director.
apicture Chhotebhai
16 Feb 2026
The cry "Why am I poor?" exposes a world where fear of the other, corrupted politics, and dollar-driven power reduce millions to "children of a lesser god." Abundance will coexist with deprivation, an
apicture Peter Fernandes
16 Feb 2026
O Water! There is a facade of democracy. In which caste is appropriated As a religious tool, To strengthen the caste hierarchy For touching their water.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
16 Feb 2026
From Washington's muscle diplomacy to Hindutva's cultural majoritarianism, a dangerous erosion of values is reshaping global and Indian politics. When power replaces principle and identity overrides j
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
16 Feb 2026
In today's world, governance is not merely about policies. It is about performance. The teleprompter screen must glow. The sentences must glide. The applause must arrive on cue.
apicture Robert Clements
16 Feb 2026
From Godhra to Assam, a once-neutral word has been weaponised to stigmatise, harass, and exclude a section of the people. This is not a linguistic accident but a political design wherein power turns l
apicture A. J. Philip
09 Feb 2026