The Quiet Rise of the Hindu Rashtra Rulebook

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
03 Feb 2025

One sometimes wonders how blind people can be when they apply perspectives. When one does something, it is lawful; when someone else does the same, it is deemed criminal. This dissembling is the hallmark of the BJP's governance, which has been having a ball silencing its critics by throwing them into the slammer weaponising draconian laws. According to an older report from 2024, around 701 had been booked on sedition charges in 2018-22. This does not include the 5023 UAPA cases registered in the same period.

Wikipedia defines sedition as "an overt conduct, such as speech or organisation, that tends toward rebellion against the established order. Sedition often includes subversion of a constitution and incitement of discontent ..."

By this definition and its previous demeanour of collecting "seditious" individuals, the government should have had already taken action against those who dared to draft a "Hindu Rashtra Constitution" and preemptively put a stop to its speculated release on Basant Panchmi.

Discarding the existing Constitution—a symbol of India's secular and democratic identity—is tantamount to declaring that the nation, as we know it, must cease to exist. The very idea of India that embraces diversity and equality is being targeted. Have the Hindutva forces decided that India must cease to exist and that it is time to wage a "Sanatani war" against all who do not subscribe to its exclusionary tenets?

The Judiciary, the supposed guardian of the Constitution, should have been more conscious that a parallel document has been penned and is being publicly flaunted as the next big thing. Why is it failing to take suo motu cognisance of this shocker? The mere speculation of an alternative constitution being drafted should have prompted immediate intervention to safeguard the national interests.

Our country stands at a crossroads today. Its citizens must rise to the occasion and demand accountability. The Constitution is not just a legal document; it is the nation's soul. Allowing actions such as these is betraying our very essence.

There are ample similitudes between the growing situation in India and countries grappling with extremist shadow governments or overwhelming mafia influence.

There are a multitude of ways that this may go. The right-wing may, like Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), operate as a shadow government, challenging the authority of the state and enforcing its own regressive ideology if the Judiciary continues to hum and haw as it does right now between joining poojas and sharing podiums from where poisonous speeches are disseminated.

Or we might become another Afghanistan where the right-wing governs like the Taliban with a worldview that erases fundamental freedoms and pluralism. The rule of law and constitutional governance will be supplanted by authoritarianism, where dissent is met with brutality, and power flows from fear rather than legitimacy.

Even in nations plagued by mafia dominance, such as certain regions of Italy or Mexico, the erosion of state authority is marked by selective law enforcement.

These systems thrive on double standards, where those who oppose the status quo are swiftly silenced while powerful actors operate with impunity. While these examples may seem distant right now, they may not be so for too long.

Recent Posts

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is overwhelming us today! AI, as we all know, is about communication, information, data mining, and much more. It shapes the way we think and even determines our behaviour
apicture Cedric Prakash
19 Oct 2026
The Indian Catholic Press Association, in collaboration with the Mumbai Province of the Salesians of Don Bosco, takes immense pride in conferring the Fr. Louis Careno Award for Excellence in Journalis
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
The Indian Catholic Press Association (ICPA) proudly presents the ICPA Award for outstanding contribution to the cause of Scheduled Castes and Dalit communities, sponsored by the CBCI Office for Sched
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
The Indian Catholic Press Association (ICPA), in collaboration with the Society of St Paul, takes immense pride in presenting the prestigious James Alberione Award to
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
The Indian Catholic Press Association (ICPA), in collaboration with the Society of St Paul, proudly confers the prestigious J. Maurus Award upon renowned Jesuit author
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
The Indian Catholic Press Association (ICPA), in collaboration with the Central India Province of the Society of the Divine Word (SVD), takes immense pride in conferring the ICPA–SVD Swami Devanand Ch
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
We, the members of the Indian Catholic Press Association (ICPA), met for the 31st National Convention of Christian Journalists on 19-20 September 2026 at Paalanaa Bhavana, Benson Town, Bengaluru.
apicture ICPA
19 Oct 2026
It was a friend in Houston, Texas, who first alerted me to the news that the Nobel Peace Prize for 2026 had gone to Navi Pillay, a South African jurist of Indian origin. He also sent me her photograph
apicture A. J. Philip
19 Oct 2026
The controversy over SIR and alleged voter deletions demands a united democratic resistance. Rahul Gandhi's efforts to bring opposition parties, civil society and student activists together are signif
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
19 Oct 2026
On September 18, 2025, Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi called a press conference in New Delhi and accused the Election Commission of India of facilitating what he called "vote c
apicture John Dayal
19 Oct 2026