hidden image

Bob’s Banter by Robert Clements Colonial Sedition and Democracy..!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
19 Jul 2021

Even as I hear the Supreme Court calling sedition, a ‘colonial’ law, I also hear that a hundred farmers have been slapped with the same ‘colonial’ law for protesting!
I agree, nobody likes his car stopped on a highway, especially a Speaker!
But that’s democracy!
Just as a government is allowed to pass laws, a democratic constitution gives citizens the right to protest against those same laws. Trying to put a protestor in jail is not democracy! Let me explain: How often we have seen our children or some other child throwing a tantrum. They shout and yell and scream a lot of nonsense. You can do two things, slap the child hard or reason with the child.
When you slap the child you never get to know the reason for the tantrum. It could be a bullying elder brother, it could be some injustice or it could also just be a spoiled brat. But in getting to know by questioning, you get to the root of the problem and a good parent, searches for a solution. Otherwise that child who has suppressed such feelings of anger will show it in some other way.
That ‘other way’ which comes out later is quite often what we call terrorism. I am not saying, all terrorism stems from not being heard, but a lot of supporters of terrorism, can be turned away from supporting terrorist activities by giving them a patient ear.
Instead we put them in jail for sedition and when you do this and a group of people realise they cannot legitimately protest they react by creating destruction! They use destruction to be heard, and think terrorism is a way of making people listen!
Such thoughts and solutions must have rankled the minds of the drafters of our Constitution when they defined the concept of Indian democracy! They gave a voice to the people, even if some were raised in anger!
Many years ago, slums in the city were horrible and filthy. But after many protests, many morchas, much inconvenience to many of us, today, when I walk into those same slums, what a dramatic change there is; clean, hygienic, and a smile on the faces of the same people who once protested on the streets, demanding cleaner living conditions!  
People heard their protests and did something. If they had not listened those same slum people could have forcibly taken over our homes or gone on to destructive ways of robberies, looting and terror!
Yes, I agree, nobody likes protests, especially we who are inconvenienced. But accept protests with as part of a healthy concept and stop using sedition as a convenient tool. It will only break our fragile democracy, we have fought so hard to retain in our country..!

bobsbanter@gmail.com

Recent Posts

GRAMG replaces a constitutional right with a capped dole. It seeks to shift costs to poorer states, punish those states where the BJP doesn't rule, centralise power in Delhi, and convert demand-driven
apicture Joseph Maliakan
22 Dec 2025
The Modi government, even in its 12th year, is on a name-changing spree, including that of MGNREGA, trying to erase the legacy of the Congress-era projects.
apicture Dr Suresh Mathew
22 Dec 2025
Gandhi is garlanded, branded and renamed into oblivion, while his ideas are quietly dismantled. Hindutva venerates his image abroad and empties his legacy at home. It is consistently replacing moral c
apicture A. J. Philip
22 Dec 2025
Christmas is celebrated everywhere, sold endlessly, and consumed noisily—yet its soul is simple: God in every human being. Beyond markets, rituals and identities, Christmas calls us to choose humanity
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
22 Dec 2025
When God, our Creator, created the world, the Holy Bible tells us he said, "Let there be Light... sky, water, earth, fish, animals..." He finally created man (Adam and Eve). Looking from above, he tel
apicture Cedric Prakash
22 Dec 2025
We are still taking censuses, still building walls, still deciding who belongs. And Christmas still comes every year, quietly asking if we have left any room, if we are willing to see God in unexpecte
apicture Dr John Singarayar
22 Dec 2025
Periyar, you preached reason and self-respect, You fought caste, oppression, and Brahminical dominance. You challenged the sacred scriptures, the rituals of the oppressors, You raised your voice fo
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
22 Dec 2025
Hindon airport shows how no-frills regional hubs can democratise flying. As aviation booms, India must back low-cost airports and diversified infrastructure, not metro congestion and monopolies, if af
apicture Pachu Menon
22 Dec 2025
India bankrolls rivals through dependence, brandishes self-reliance as a slogan, humiliates neighbours and minorities alike, and mistakes bravado for strength. History warns that nations weakened by r
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
22 Dec 2025
Climate change is hitting India hardest—weakening agriculture, deepening poverty, worsening health risks, and driving unsafe urban migration. Building resilience, enforcing climate justice, and aligni
apicture Fr. John Felix Raj & Prabhat Kumar Datta
22 Dec 2025