hidden image

Churchgate, Churches and Choirs..!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
19 Feb 2024

I was saddened to hear that 'Churchgate', the most recognised railway station in the country, was being renamed. Churchgate, signified many decades ago, the entrance gate to the Fort of Bombay, where a church stood. So, the gate got to be called 'Churchgate' and since the station was built down the same road, it bore the same name.

Just imagine the unfolding of pages of history, with just a name opening it up. And that history belongs to you and me, with nobody having the right to take it away from the present or future generations. The present generation is just stewards or caretakers of an heirloom that is theirs to safeguard for a period of time.

I see the same happening elsewhere: A church choir in good ole Madras, now Chennai, decided to have a reunion of its old members, many who'd sung in it more than fifty years ago. They flew down from all over the world and asked the 'present' church board permission to sing on a Sunday but were given a firm 'no'. The reason being they were not part of the choir anymore. Shouldn't the present board members have realised they were just stewards of the church, and that the church's history also belonged to the old choir members. But they made the mistake of imagining they were the 'owners' of time!

When stewards think they are owners, catastrophe ensues, and the environmental issues we face today are mostly because of that. If our children are going to inherit an earth that has been wrecked through our callousness and carelessness, then their sicknesses and health issues have only us to blame. Imagining we were the owners of the earth, we passed on a sick and dying planet to them. As murderers, we deserve the sentence of the death penalty.

The same sentence is applicable to those who rename roads, cities, towns and stations. They are taking away from future generations their link to their roots. And those on that church board deserve no less a punishment. They took away from the present congregation the right to listen to music and choral singing their fathers had grown up on. History was literally torn out of their grasp.

It's like a billionaire shouting, and many do so, "I am a self-made man"! "Self-made man"? Whispers his dead mother from the grave, "It was I who carried him to school". "And I, who paid his fees, working overtime!" nods his father also from the grave.

I can hear the walls of that same church in Vepery whisper, "Those choral voices of old built the love for singing the present congregation now has!"

But till we change our attitude from being owners to realising we are stewards for a slot of time, such warning whispers from walls and graves will go unheard, and future generations will be robbed of their rightful heritage!

bobsbanter@gmail.com   

Recent Posts

GRAMG replaces a constitutional right with a capped dole. It seeks to shift costs to poorer states, punish those states where the BJP doesn't rule, centralise power in Delhi, and convert demand-driven
apicture Joseph Maliakan
22 Dec 2025
The Modi government, even in its 12th year, is on a name-changing spree, including that of MGNREGA, trying to erase the legacy of the Congress-era projects.
apicture Dr Suresh Mathew
22 Dec 2025
Gandhi is garlanded, branded and renamed into oblivion, while his ideas are quietly dismantled. Hindutva venerates his image abroad and empties his legacy at home. It is consistently replacing moral c
apicture A. J. Philip
22 Dec 2025
Christmas is celebrated everywhere, sold endlessly, and consumed noisily—yet its soul is simple: God in every human being. Beyond markets, rituals and identities, Christmas calls us to choose humanity
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
22 Dec 2025
When God, our Creator, created the world, the Holy Bible tells us he said, "Let there be Light... sky, water, earth, fish, animals..." He finally created man (Adam and Eve). Looking from above, he tel
apicture Cedric Prakash
22 Dec 2025
We are still taking censuses, still building walls, still deciding who belongs. And Christmas still comes every year, quietly asking if we have left any room, if we are willing to see God in unexpecte
apicture Dr John Singarayar
22 Dec 2025
Periyar, you preached reason and self-respect, You fought caste, oppression, and Brahminical dominance. You challenged the sacred scriptures, the rituals of the oppressors, You raised your voice fo
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
22 Dec 2025
Hindon airport shows how no-frills regional hubs can democratise flying. As aviation booms, India must back low-cost airports and diversified infrastructure, not metro congestion and monopolies, if af
apicture Pachu Menon
22 Dec 2025
India bankrolls rivals through dependence, brandishes self-reliance as a slogan, humiliates neighbours and minorities alike, and mistakes bravado for strength. History warns that nations weakened by r
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
22 Dec 2025
Climate change is hitting India hardest—weakening agriculture, deepening poverty, worsening health risks, and driving unsafe urban migration. Building resilience, enforcing climate justice, and aligni
apicture Fr. John Felix Raj & Prabhat Kumar Datta
22 Dec 2025