hidden image

Losing Pitch Together!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
24 Aug 2026

There is a frightening moment in choral singing when the entire choir begins to lose pitch.

Nobody notices it at first.

The sopranos are singing confidently. The altos are following the sopranos. The tenors are following the altos. And basses, being naturally humble people, are following everybody while looking as if everybody is following us.

The strange thing is that we all sound correct to one another.

We are united. We are disciplined. We are singing the same song. We may even be smiling proudly at the audience.

Unfortunately, we are all wrong.

This happens especially when a choir sings without accompaniment. Slowly, almost politely, the pitch begins to slip. One voice moves slightly. Another adjusts to it. A third follows. Soon the whole choir has travelled somewhere the composer never intended it to go.

But because everyone has travelled together, nobody feels lost.

In my soon-to-be-released book, One Note at a Time, I write about this curious problem of losing pitch together. And today, as I look at my country, I realise we are doing exactly that.

Oh yes, millions may repeat the same slogan. Thousands may applaud the same speech. Television anchors may shout the same conclusion. Social media groups may forward the same message. And because so many people are singing it together, we assume it must be true.

But numbers do not determine pitch.

A majority can sing the wrong note.

A crowd can march confidently in the wrong direction.

A nation can applaud while its freedoms quietly disappear backstage.
The problem is that nobody wants to be the lone singer who stops and says, "Excuse me, but have we moved away from the original note?"

He is immediately glared at.

"Everyone else is singing correctly," he is told.

"But we have dropped," he whispers.

"Anti choir!" somebody shouts.

"Enemy of harmony!" cries another.

Soon he is removed from the rehearsal, and the choir continues magnificently towards musical disaster.

The conductor does not ask whether the wrong note is popular. He asks whether it is right. Democracy must learn to ask the same question before applause becomes noise.

A wise choir keeps returning to the tuning note. A wise nation must also keep returning to its Constitution, its conscience, its compassion, and its commitment to truth.

These are the notes that tell us whether we are still singing the song our founders gave us.

Unity is beautiful, but only when united around what is right. Otherwise, unity merely allows everyone to become lost without feeling lonely.
So when the crowd grows louder, listen more carefully.

We may be singing together.

But stop singing, listen carefully, and ask yourself, "am I still in tune?"

Recent Posts

Corrective press notes are not substitutes for accountability. This crisis demands independent investigation, judicial scrutiny and reversal of the SIR. Institutional complicity is the gravest betraya
apicture Oliver D'Souza
05 Oct 2026
The revelations have shattered public confidence in the Election Commission. Gyanesh Kumar's continuance as Chief Election Commissioner is untenable. Whether through resignation or impeachment, he mus
apicture Cedric Prakash
05 Oct 2026
It was never the powerful, privileged or educated who kept Indian democracy alive, but the poor who queued under the scorching sun to exercise their franchise. Now, the very machinery entrusted with p
apicture A. J. Philip
05 Oct 2026
The Opposition has a historic opportunity to unite against the erosion of electoral integrity and defend citizens' fundamental right to vote. Delayed response, political fragmentation and narrow inter
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 Oct 2026
India's institutions were supposed to be built on merit, independence and constitutional accountability. Yet, beneath their lofty credentials, kinship networks quietly reproduce privilege, compromise
apicture John Dayal
05 Oct 2026
Article 342 of the Constitution of India empowers the President to officially specify indigenous tribes, tribal communities, or specific groups within them as "Scheduled Tribes," in consultation with
apicture Pachu Menon
05 Oct 2026
I have seen the professional anti-caste intellectual. S/He arrives. S/He speaks. S/He refers to Ambedkar. S/He cites John Rawls. S/He quotes Michael Foucault.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
05 Oct 2026
Before recording a crime, obtain written consent from everyone involved
apicture Robert Clements
05 Oct 2026
How can greater knowledge be accompanied by greater wisdom, greater prosperity by greater solidarity, greater power by greater responsibility, and greater connectivity by genuine human fraternity?
apicture Br. Dr. Lawrence Soosai Nathan, OFM Cap.
28 Sep 2026
"Deus meus et omnia" ("My God and my All!") was St. Francis of Assisi's favourite prayer. According to early Franciscan accounts, most notably recorded by Brother Bernard of Quintavalle, Francis's fir
apicture Br. Cyriac George, OFM Cap.
28 Sep 2026