Hate Breeds at Home

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
19 May 2025

By its nature, hate respects no boundaries—geographic, religious, communal, or moral. In failing to confront Hindutva extremist hate speech decisively, India has jeopardised its existence and that of the people who live within it.

In a degrading display of Sanatana Dharma, Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri faced a vicious onslaught from the Hindutva fold following his announcement of the India-Pakistan ceasefire on May 10, a decision that was, by the way, taken by the top. The venomous abuse was not only aimed at the messenger but extended even to his daughter, a lawyer who has defended members of the Rohingya community. The sheer pettiness and crudeness of the attacks laid bare, once again, the ideological rot and disturbed psyche behind the rhetoric of Hindutva crusaders.

These are not isolated incidents. Madhya Pradesh Minister Kunwar Vijay Shah's vulgar language in describing Colonel Sofia Qureshi at a public rally in Mhow is a glimpse of what the Indian mindset is moving towards, and the consequences are not going to be pleasant. When it was felt that his remarks would not go unchecked, the BJP lightly rapped him on the knuckles and tried to justify him. The fact that he is still a minister and that the BJP top guns are silent on this issue evidences that his words are the BJP's. Though the Jabalpur High Court has taken cognisance of the vitriol and declared it "language of the gutters," it remains to be seen if it leads to anything.

Himanshi Narwal, who the BJP tried to make the "poster girl" of their campaign, soon became the target of their diatribes when she called for peace. She was vilified and silenced, and was character assassinated. Whether they dug into her past or picked apart her education, speculated about her future choices or hurled crude insults at her private life, the trolls attacked every facet of her character, questioning her integrity, her motives, and every single detail.

Not just Himanshi Narwal, Arathi Menon, who lost her father in the same deadly terrorist attack in Pahalgam, was also subjected to online trolling. For Menon, the backlash began when she shared that the tragedy had given her two brothers.

Generally, women became easy pickings as they are sexualised and attacked by the hatemongers who, faithful to the teachings of Manu, are deeply misogynistic and casteist.

While the Indian army exchanges blows with threats without, a war is being waged within the country against its own minorities. The nauseating display should suffice to show saffron supporters of what everything they stand for will eventually devolve into.

And yet, outrage remains muted. Political leaders have offered half hearted condemnations while perpetrators roam free; social media platforms fail to moderate abusive content; law enforcement drags its feet on enforcing provisions against hate speech. This climate of impunity sends a brutal message: that targeting the vulnerable is not only tolerated but is tacitly endorsed. It is going to be the new normal.

Recent Posts

Whatever may be your personal beliefs, your commitment is to protect the Constitution in all respects. And it mandates you to be just and fair to one and all—tribals, non-tribals, Christians, Muslims,
apicture A. J. Philip
02 Jun 2025
The Supreme Court, while quashing fake FIRs against conversion, citing procedural violations and lack of evidence, criticised the UP Police for conducting a mechanical and biased investigation, warnin
apicture Joseph Maliakan
02 Jun 2025
Pope Leo XIV's vision of peace, dialogue, and synodality resonates deeply with the needs of the Indian Church. Amid religious polarisation, internal conflict, and social injustice, Indian Catholics se
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
02 Jun 2025
India's $4 trillion GDP milestone is impressive, but it hides deep inequalities. For millions still struggling to meet their basic needs, growth on paper means little. Real progress lies not in aggreg
apicture Jaswant Kaur
02 Jun 2025
On the 59th World Day of Social Communications, Pope Francis urges a disarmed, hope-filled approach to communication amid global turmoil. In India, where media freedom is eroding, Catholic communicato
apicture Cedric Prakash
02 Jun 2025
The Pahalgam attack briefly united India, but the undercurrents are revealing widening chasms. While voices for peace like Prof. Ali Khan face arrest, hate speech by political leaders is normalised.
apicture Ram Puniyani
02 Jun 2025
Bangladesh faces political instability, economic collapse, and regional tensions. The interim Yunus government struggles as the civil unrest deepens, relations with India sour and Islamist forces are
apicture Sacaria Joseph
02 Jun 2025
It's the same with success. "I want to shine!" we declare. Heaven obliges—with a few storms to test your waterproofing. And suddenly, we're ducking under tables, hiding from opportunity disguised as i
apicture Robert Clements
02 Jun 2025
PM Modi's three-point doctrine emphasises zero tolerance for terrorism, a rejection of nuclear blackmail, and decisive responses to attacks. He would do well to draw parallels domestically. There must
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
26 May 2025
The role played by the Brothers in evangelisation, education, and social upliftment cannot be overstated. I do not know how many people are aware that at least two Brothers are on the road to canonisa
apicture A. J. Philip
26 May 2025