The Uneven Hand of Regulation

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
06 Apr 2026

The BJP government's hypocrisy is revealed even more clearly as it tightens the noose, especially on minorities. One of the latest additions to its growing list of atrocities is the FCRA amendment, which is weaponised against minorities. At the same time, its mothership, the RSS, an unregistered organisation, continues to gather funds with unrestricted derogation.

This draconian Bill, which was already amended on multiple occasions previously to bring minorities to their knees, now empowers the arbitrary takeover of everything which was built with the FCRA funds. The new provisions go far beyond regulatory oversight. By enabling the government to appoint a "designated authority" to assume control over the funds and assets of organisations whose licences are cancelled or allowed to lapse, the State arrogates to itself sweeping powers that are open to misuse.

This is largely detrimental, as these assets include schools, hospitals, shelters, and community infrastructure painstakingly built over decades, often through pooling foreign and domestic contributions. The possibility that such assets may be seized, managed, or even disposed of at the discretion of the authorities introduces a climate of deep uncertainty, not just for organisations but for the vulnerable communities they serve.

Contrary to the words of the Kerala BJP, the concerns expressed by civil society and religious bodies are neither exaggerated nor misplaced. The apprehension that these amendments could enable executive overreach into constitutionally protected freedoms deserves serious attention. The right to association, the autonomy of institutions, and the freedom to pursue charitable and educational work without undue interference are not concessions granted by the State; they are integral to the functioning of a democratic society.

It is here that the government's position appears particularly untenable. While registered organisations are subjected to ever-tightening scrutiny, entities aligned with the ideological ecosystem of the ruling establishment appear to operate without comparable constraints.

The political response has reflected this divide. Opposition parties have termed the amendments arbitrary and unconstitutional, arguing that they offend fundamental rights and further centralise control. Protests in Parliament and outside it accentuate the growing unease. Yet, the government has shown little inclination to engage meaningfully with these concerns, choosing instead to press ahead under the cover of legislative authority.

The reported decision to hold the Bill in abeyance in view of electoral considerations in States with significant minority populations, especially Kerala, only reinforces the impression that principle is subordinate to expediency.

While the government has put a temporary halt on the Bill, it does not seem very keen on retracting the legislation. We may well see it come back and be applied with brute force once the elections conclude.

Recent Posts

A diplomatic dinner is more than a meal; it is cultural diplomacy on a plate. India has every right to showcase its magnificent vegetarian cuisine, but excluding its equally rich non-vegetarian tradit
apicture A. J. Philip
21 Sep 2026
Ageing need not mean becoming a burden. With the right opportunities, senior citizens can remain productive, creative and socially engaged. Kerala's emerging Silver Economy offers the Church and civil
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
21 Sep 2026
Congress asked Karnataka's Christians to trust its promise to repeal the anti-conversion law. Three years later, the law remains. Repeated meetings, assurances and memoranda have only served to produc
apicture John Dayal
21 Sep 2026
Accountability is travelling from official files to the grassroots. "School Thik Karo" may be satire's latest avatar, but its questions about India's public schools are real.
apicture Pachu Menon
21 Sep 2026
India's education system is in terminal decline because of short-sightedness and corrupt, incompetent academic leadership. The public education system is practically dismantled. Ever since the Nationa
apicture G Ramachandram
21 Sep 2026
A major strength of the book is that Menamparampil does not examine these issues merely as political or theological problems. He approaches them through human relationships, collective identities, soc
apicture K. Jose, SVD
21 Sep 2026
I am tired of the Indian theorists MN Srinivas, Bhikku Parekh, Ashish Nandy, Akeel Bilgrami,
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
21 Sep 2026
The voter is sovereign. The electoral roll exists for the voter. The election exists for the voter. The government ultimately derives legitimacy from the voter. When crores disappear from electoral ro
apicture Oliver D'Souza
21 Sep 2026
The Bible is filled with rulers who believed they could contain God. Today, their thrones are gone, their empires are history, and many of their names are remembered only because they tried to stop Hi
apicture Robert Clements
21 Sep 2026
India's daughters are still treated as someone else's property, burdened by patriarchy, denied autonomy and forced to surrender independence. Rahul Gandhi's women-only gathering in Pune challenged thi
apicture G Ramachandram
14 Sep 2026