hidden image

The Citizen Controversy: A Hydrogen Balloon to Fool People

Joseph Maliakan Joseph Maliakan
06 Jul 2026

Whoever thought of coming out with the statement that the Indian passport is only a mere document for travel and is not proof of Indian citizenship is a great genius! It has led the whole nation to discuss the criteria for acquiring Indian citizenship. It has also compelled me, a veteran journalist aged 78, to wonder whether I am an Indian citizen, even though, using the Indian passport, which boldly declares that I am a Citizen of India, I have travelled to many countries.

I first acquired a passport in 1979. At that time, I was working for The Indian Express in Delhi as a reporter. I was assigned to embark on an Indian Naval cruise on the training ship INS Brahmaputra, bound for Thailand and Indonesia. I approached the Regional Passport Officer at his Shastri Bhavan office with the invitation from the Defence Ministry. I was issued an Indian passport in five minutes.

There was no police verification, nor did the RPO ask for any documents, such as a birth certificate, school-leaving certificate, or appointment letter. The passport was issued as if it were a citizen's right, and the State's duty was to issue a passport to any citizen who asked for one. The State, unlike now, had full trust in the citizen back then. The Passport Office accepted whatever I wrote in the application form as gospel truth!

Unlike today, my first passport, issued on September 29, 1979, was stamped "CITIZEN OF INDIA" in capital letters. The first page of the passport, first in Hindi and then in English, stated: "These are to request and require, in the Name of the President of the Republic of India, all those whom it may concern to allow the bearer to pass freely without let or hindrance, and to afford him or her every assistance and protection of which he or she may stand in need."

In fact, people need not be anxious about their citizenship on any count. Indian citizenship is clearly governed by the Citizenship Act, 1955, and can be acquired through four primary pathways: birth, descent, registration, and naturalisation. India does not allow dual citizenship.

If you were born between January 26, 1950 and June 30, 1987, you are a citizen by birth regardless of your parents' nationality. If you were born between July 1, 1987 and December 2, 2004, you are a citizen of India if at least one parent was a citizen of India at the time of your birth. And if you were born after December 3, 2004, you are an Indian citizen if both parents are Indian citizens, or if one parent is an Indian citizen and the other is not an illegal immigrant.

Indian citizens born at the time of the Constitution's commencement on January 26, 1950, acquired citizenship under Article 5. At the commencement of the Constitution, every person who had his domicile in the territory of India, or either of whose parents was born in the territory of India, or who had been ordinarily resident in the territory of India for not less than five years immediately preceding such commencement, became a citizen of India.

Then how did the present confusion arise? To justify the unnamed Ministry of External Affairs official's false statement that the passport is not proof of citizenship, the bureaucracy deliberately misquoted a 2013 Bombay High Court judgment. The High Court, in its order dated July 26, 2013, did not even consider whether a passport was proof of one's citizenship.

All that the Court said was that, in the case of Anwar Hussain Abdul Kadar Shaikh and Others vs State of Maharashtra, the passport produced was a "terminated" one. Therefore, it did not take it into consideration while deciding the petitioner's claim regarding citizenship. The relevant portion of the judgment stated: "However, the passport to which the learned counsel gave reference is already terminated passport. Therefore, no legal basis can be achieved for its reliance." The Bombay High Court did not examine the merit of the passport as a document to prove the applicant's citizenship.

However, there is no denying that anyone who holds an Indian passport is an Indian citizen, though citizens do not need a passport to prove their citizenship. And in a country like India, where millions do not have documents to prove their citizenship, it would be a travesty of justice to deny citizenship, or even to doubt the citizenship, of those who hold Indian passports.

Recent Posts

India's daughters are still treated as someone else's property, burdened by patriarchy, denied autonomy and forced to surrender independence. Rahul Gandhi's women-only gathering in Pune challenged thi
apicture G Ramachandram
14 Sep 2026
If changing the Constitution is difficult, changing the electorate may prove easier. SIR's mass deletions raise the disturbing possibility that Hindutva's route to a Hindu Rashtra may run not through
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
14 Sep 2026
This writer must admit to a vested interest in this story, as the Election Commission office in New Delhi erased his wife from the national capital territory's electoral rolls, and restored it only af
apicture John Dayal
14 Sep 2026
Reservation is not charity; it is a constitutional instrument of social justice. But leaving sanctioned posts vacant, replacing permanent employment with contracts and privatising public institutions
apicture Joseph Maliakan
14 Sep 2026
Children do not always need another lecture, correction or punishment. Sometimes they need an adult willing to listen beneath the behaviour and discover the unmet need. The language we use can rebuild
apicture Dr Arnald Mahesh SDB
14 Sep 2026
A 7.8 per cent GDP growth rate makes for an impressive headline. But GDP does not pay the rent, buy food or protect a worker from illness or unemployment. The country's growth remains incomplete until
apicture Jose Vattakuzhy
14 Sep 2026
He may speak of purity and pollution, tradition and order, custom and inherited authority.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
14 Sep 2026
To commemorate this historic occasion, the Departments of History, Sociology and Political Science organised a one-day state-level seminar in collaboration with the Internal Quality Assurance Cell (IQ
apicture Isaac Gomes
14 Sep 2026
Gentlemen, before telling women to stay at home, remember that the doctor saving your life, the judge protecting your rights, or the pilot flying your plane may be a woman.
apicture Robert Clements
14 Sep 2026
The RSS has spent decades building an international ecosystem of charities, cultural bodies, donors and political influence. Bhagwat's centenary outreach seeks to consolidate it. The West has noticed.
apicture Oliver D'Souza
07 Sep 2026