The New Architecture of Worker Insecurity

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
01 Dec 2025

Whether or not it is consistent in anything good, though it is consistent in its evil ways, the incumbent government has taken upon itself to consistently accessorise its shenanigans with adjectives like historic, path-breaking, ground-breaking, revolutionary, etc. The latest in these exploits is the release of the four new labour codes coming close on the heels of the BJP's victory in Bihar. It claims that these will streamline the existing governance of anyone holding a job in any sector.

While these Codes have been touted as par excellence and nothing short of miraculous, what is not said is that those praising them are the business houses, who now need no excuse to boot employees after the fact and refuse them benefits. The majority of the Indian working classes have become vociferous at this manifest betrayal. All labour unions, barring those backed by the BJP-RSS, have protested the implementation of these laws. Ironically, the majoritarianism of the BJP-RSS, who push for a Hindu nation, withers away where their noses begin.

To commence withal, these Codes are entirely arbitrary and misaligned, not to mention incomplete - leave it to the BJP to fail even at copying what has already been explicated in documents progressively since Independence. Instead of simplifying, codifying, revising, and modernising existing laws for the benefit of the people and in line with the signs of the times, the policymakers have decided to throw away decades of hard-earned workers' rights. It should not be surprising that these portray regressive tendencies, much in line with other BJP proclivities.

The government avers that it conducted extensive tripartite consultations in the manufacturing of these codes. However, it is a blatant lie. The truth is that these were concocted in secret, without any parliamentary discussion or consultation with those impacted. How could it have consulted stakeholders, given that the Indian Labour Conference (ILC) has not been held since its 46th session in July 2015?

The government has deliberately bypassed the ILC process to push through the four new labour codes to push its own agenda. While 10 Central Trade Unions (CTUs) unanimously opposed it, their opposition, arguments, and evidence were drowned out by studied muteness.

Much of what is being propagated by the "experts," the Godi media and the BJP are hogwash plated in silvery foil. The BJP claims that everyone will benefit equally with fixed-term employment. That would only mean permanence of temporariness in core and perennial jobs. It would replace all permanent jobs with short-term contracts, favourable to employers, since they can then run through any number of employees at that position. There would be a loss of service continuity, seniority, and actual benefits.

The much-publicised social security for gig and platform workers also does not hold up to scrutiny. There are no defined benefits, no fund allocation, no timelines, not to mention the complete absence of the employer-employee relationship. Linking Aadhaar to anything won't help. How will digitalisation help the illiterate, who constitute a vast demographic in India? Who will issue employment letters to the billions in the unorganised sector?

The facade of a minimum wage for all is deceptive. Instead, many states which fare comparatively better will be forced to lower their existing minimums. Millions, including scheme workers, will be excluded from minimum wages, forget a living wage.

When we see the government giving the option of self-assessment, where employers can self-declare their compliance, exempting them from regular inspections for a period of three to five years, which is basically a license for flouting laws, we must ask - where are we headed?

Recent Posts

From Serbia to Brazil, Israel, the United States and India, people are challenging authoritarianism, corruption, communalism and war. A global awakening is gathering momentum, with youth-led movements
apicture Cedric Prakash
09 Nov 2026
India's Gen Z has punctured Modi's carefully manufactured grandeur and galvanised a nationwide resistance. Despite brutal repression, the people's movement continues to challenge authoritarianism, dem
apicture Mathew John
09 Nov 2026
Mumbai BJP Chief Ameet Satam posted sharp criticism on X, saying citizens did not need "lessons on how to celebrate Diwali" from Dia Mirza. Within hours, the civic body deleted the video. Mumbai Mayor
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
09 Nov 2026
The BJP's electoral dominance rests not merely on Modi's charisma, money or media control, but on a permanent grassroots machinery combining RSS cadre, booth-level voter intelligence, AI-driven campai
apicture John Dayal
09 Nov 2026
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed that constitutional safeguards cannot be circumvented through procedural manipulation. The 24-hour deadline for producing an accused before a Magistrate begins when li
apicture Jessy Kurian
09 Nov 2026
Catholic health care must resist the commodification of human life and rediscover its Gospel mandate to serve the poor. Financial sustainability cannot eclipse compassion, dignity and trust. Healing i
apicture Mario Vaz, CCBI Bioethics Forum
09 Nov 2026
A People's Tribunal in Kolkata documented at least 48 cases of alleged persecution of Christians in West Bengal. Victims recounted violence, intimidation and religious discrimination owing to the grow
apicture Fr. Sunil Rosario
09 Nov 2026
Christian missionary institutions have helped shape modern India through education, healthcare and social reform. Yet the Sangh Parivar questions their patriotism and motives. Its own leaders benefite
apicture P. A. Chacko
09 Nov 2026
Perhaps the common man should stop saying, "I cannot breathe," and start saying, "I cannot vote." Watch how quickly the minister opens his window. Watch how urgently he demands action.
apicture Robert Clements
09 Nov 2026
From Socrates and Jesus to Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr., history bears witness to the use of character assassination to silence dissent. In contemporary India, manufactured labels and personal at
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
02 Nov 2026