hidden image

Bihar and Prashant Kishor!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
17 Nov 2025

As I look at the Bihar election results, I am not going to spend time on the poor show by the opposition. I have always maintained that unless the Congress and other parties pull up their socks and come up with a clear agenda for progress, they will continue to struggle.

An agenda cannot be built only on the idea of pulling down Modi.

That is not a policy. That is not a plan.

But let me turn to someone who deserves a little more attention. Prashant Kishor. Now, here is another kettle of fish entirely. For years, we have heard about this master strategist, the man behind the scenes who whispers into the ears of leaders, telling them which caste block to lean on, which community grouping to court, which doorstep to knock on and which slogan to chant. He created an aura around himself, and much of the country believed that this man understood the pulse of India.

Then, suddenly, he decided to step out of the shadows, form his own party, and stand before the very people he claimed to understand so well. And what happened? A complete washout.

Not even a small corner of Bihar decided to give him a chance.

It reminds me of something that happened in Mumbai a few decades ago. A newspaper distributor who controlled a major part of the distribution network decided that, since he delivered the newspapers, he could very well publish his own.

He believed that the power lay in the hands that carried the bundle, not in the minds that created the content. So he launched his own paper and waited for Mumbai to cheer. Within a year, the paper folded up. Vendors cannot make headlines. Delivery boys cannot write editorials. And a distribution network cannot replace the trust and talent that go into real journalism.

Why did the paper collapse? Because what matters is content. It always has and always will. And that is precisely the lesson Prashant Kishor should learn from this election. The Indian voter is not a pawn on a chessboard. He is not a numbered statistic in a caste ledger. She is not a community block you move from one column to another. The voter thinks. The voter feels. The voter judges. And above all, the voter chooses.

Kishor assumed that strategy alone wins elections. Bihar has shown him otherwise. A strategist can design a campaign, but he cannot manufacture trust. He can draw charts and create slogans, but he cannot create a connection with people by simply declaring that he knows best.

Until our opposition stops treating elections as clever games of combinations, of hurried alliances stitched only to topple others, and instead treats voters as thinking individuals, the ballot box will keep reminding them with painful clarity the very truth the newspaper vendor turned publisher discovered to his chagrin years ago: without real content, you lose...

Recent Posts

India's oldest mountain range is facing its most modern threat. As mining expands and legal definitions narrow, the Aravallis' role as a climate shield, water source, and wildlife corridor is being qu
apicture Joseph Jerald SJ
05 Jan 2026
India was built by defying religious orthodoxy, not sanctifying it. Science, education and equality advanced when prejudice was challenged—and regressed whenever cultural nationalism revives the fears
apicture A. J. Philip
05 Jan 2026
The end of a year offers individuals, institutions, nations, and the global community an opportunity for introspection and learning from the experiences of the past twelve months. Life is a blend of s
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
05 Jan 2026
The 2025 Zilla Panchayat elections exposed how local self-governance in Goa has been overtaken by high-stakes party politics. BJP's all-out mobilisation contrasted sharply with the fragmented Oppositi
apicture Pachu Menon
05 Jan 2026
In recent years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has repeatedly reached out to India's Christian community. On several occasions, especially around Christmas, he has visited churches, hosted gatherings w
apicture Bishop Savio Fernandes
05 Jan 2026
Christmas violence against Christians is diagnostic. It is a stress test of India's constitutional guarantees. Vigilantes policing public celebration with impunity is an attack on civic space.
apicture Oliver D'Souza
05 Jan 2026
Give work to all the hands Give wages to all the families
apicture Prakash Louis
05 Jan 2026
I was born like anyone else. Yet I was never treated like anyone else. The name Pariah was given to me. And its meaning was carved into my skin.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
05 Jan 2026
While Xi Jinping was at Mahabalipuram admiring Indian art and listening to Modi's 'political wisdom,' the People's Liberation Army was pushing the Chinese frontier in the Galwan Valley. The Chinese sp
apicture Archbp Thomas Menamparampil
05 Jan 2026