hidden image

The Tip of the Conversion Iceberg!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
26 Oct 2026

"Have you taken permission to believe?" I can almost hear an official asking, adjusting his spectacles and searching for the appropriate form. "God may have called you, but has He submitted the necessary documents? These heavenly communications must come through the proper channel, preferably in triplicate, with two passport photographs."

Jesuit deacon Basil Hadde's planned ordination in Chhattisgarh was reportedly postponed after officials demanded documents concerning his family's conversion to Christianity in 1995. Imagine preparing to become a priest, only to discover that somebody has reopened your spiritual admission file from thirty years ago. Even universities usually lose interest sooner.

But beneath the paperwork lies a disturbing question. Does the citizen possess a mind capable of choosing a faith? Or must that mind be deposited at the district office, where someone considerably busier, and presumably wiser, decides which direction its prayers should travel? Apparently, heaven now requires administrative clearance.

Freedom of conscience protects something deeply personal: our beliefs and the choices through which we express them. Courts have recognised the importance of individual autonomy in matters of faith. Of course, coercion and fraud deserve investigation. But choosing freely is hardly the same thing as being forced to choose.

Otherwise, we arrive at a peculiar arrangement. You may earn a living, raise children and pay taxes, but choosing your God requires supervision. The government trusts you to finance the nation, yet apparently doubts you can safely manage your own soul.

And suddenly, I find myself looking beyond the church door towards the polling booth.

Different institutions, different procedures, certainly.

Yet the same democratic principle stands there waiting: the citizen must remain free to choose, even when those holding power dislike the choice.

Allegations of "vote chori" require evidence and investigation. Electoral revision, including SIR, has a legitimate purpose: accurate rolls that retain every eligible voter. That is the stated objective. But any wrongful exclusion demands correction, because tidying the electoral register must never become a method of tidying away inconvenient citizens.

Imagine a waiter announcing, "Sir, we respect your freedom to order dinner. Unfortunately, we have removed everything you like from the menu." When you protest, he smiles reassuringly. "Please understand, this is for your protection. You have repeatedly demonstrated a dangerous tendency to choose dishes the management does not recommend."

That is the paternalism we must challenge. "You cannot choose your God, so we shall supervise." "You might choose the wrong politician, so let us narrow your options."

A democracy cannot treat adults as children whenever their decisions cause discomfort. Citizens elect governments; governments do not acquire custody of citizens' minds.

Perhaps this postponed ordination is the tip of an iceberg worth examining. Beneath it may lie that enormous, chilling assumption that power knows better than the people.

Do remember, however, that the Titanic had every confidence in its arrangements too. What sank it was what remained hidden below the surface, unseen until disaster...
 

Recent Posts

From Serbia to Brazil, Israel, the United States and India, people are challenging authoritarianism, corruption, communalism and war. A global awakening is gathering momentum, with youth-led movements
apicture Cedric Prakash
09 Nov 2026
India's Gen Z has punctured Modi's carefully manufactured grandeur and galvanised a nationwide resistance. Despite brutal repression, the people's movement continues to challenge authoritarianism, dem
apicture Mathew John
09 Nov 2026
Mumbai BJP Chief Ameet Satam posted sharp criticism on X, saying citizens did not need "lessons on how to celebrate Diwali" from Dia Mirza. Within hours, the civic body deleted the video. Mumbai Mayor
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
09 Nov 2026
The BJP's electoral dominance rests not merely on Modi's charisma, money or media control, but on a permanent grassroots machinery combining RSS cadre, booth-level voter intelligence, AI-driven campai
apicture John Dayal
09 Nov 2026
The Supreme Court has reaffirmed that constitutional safeguards cannot be circumvented through procedural manipulation. The 24-hour deadline for producing an accused before a Magistrate begins when li
apicture Jessy Kurian
09 Nov 2026
Catholic health care must resist the commodification of human life and rediscover its Gospel mandate to serve the poor. Financial sustainability cannot eclipse compassion, dignity and trust. Healing i
apicture Mario Vaz, CCBI Bioethics Forum
09 Nov 2026
A People's Tribunal in Kolkata documented at least 48 cases of alleged persecution of Christians in West Bengal. Victims recounted violence, intimidation and religious discrimination owing to the grow
apicture Fr. Sunil Rosario
09 Nov 2026
Christian missionary institutions have helped shape modern India through education, healthcare and social reform. Yet the Sangh Parivar questions their patriotism and motives. Its own leaders benefite
apicture P. A. Chacko
09 Nov 2026
Perhaps the common man should stop saying, "I cannot breathe," and start saying, "I cannot vote." Watch how quickly the minister opens his window. Watch how urgently he demands action.
apicture Robert Clements
09 Nov 2026
From Socrates and Jesus to Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr., history bears witness to the use of character assassination to silence dissent. In contemporary India, manufactured labels and personal at
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
02 Nov 2026