Women's Reservation Held Hostage

Carol Andrade Carol Andrade
27 Apr 2026

On April 17, in a rare show of unity, the Opposition came together to defeat a piece of legislation the Modi government was most keen to pass.

This was the Constitution (131st Amendment) Bill, 2026, along with two other Delimitation Bills that were automatically withdrawn once the first fell through.

That it fell through was not a surprise. The Opposition has always viewed the Delimitation exércise, aimed at increasing representation in Parliament from 543 to 850 MPs, based on the 2011 census, through the lens of suspicion.

Nor does it require a keen understanding of the political process to realise how this will benefit the BJP. The North, much less progressive, with human development indices usually well below the national average, outnumbers the developed, forward-looking South handily when it comes to population. So while Delimitation must be undertaken, assurances on various parameters are sought to ensure the South is not punished for its economic outlook.

So, where does the issue of women's reservation come into the picture? After all, the Nari Shakti Vandan Adhiniyam - or the Women's Reservation Bill - was passed in 2023 as the Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023, guaranteeing 33 per cent reservation for them in the Lok Sabha, state legislative assemblies, and the Delhi Council. It came into force on April 16.

Days before the Delimitation Bill was due to be passed, the Prime Minister urged Parliament to come together "to support women" by ensuring a smooth process. With election rallies in full swing in TN and in West Bengal, both Modi and Home Minister Amit Shah kept the matter before the public eye. The mainstream media dutifully reported what they said.

After the defeat, a first for the NDA in 12 years, these voices were further amplified. The women of India would never forgive them, the PM thundered. The Opposition has clearly shown it was anti-women, he declared.

The facts are rather different. Observe the chronology. In 2023, the Women's Reservation Bill finally landed. It was passed UNANIMOUSLY, thus contradicting the claim that the Opposition is anti-women. On April 16, 2026, just a week ago, it came into force.

The Delimitation Bill to be passed was allegedly received by some members only on April 14. And it "built upon" the Women's Reservation Act, 2023, by linking its implementation to a future Census and Delimitation Exercise, possibly before the next general election in 2029.

That's what brought the Opposition together. Nor has the uproar died down yet. Why not implement women's reservation now, immediately? Why wait for Delimitation? Why should we accept assurances that the South will suffer when none of these has been laid down in the Bill itself, they ask.

The ruling party has some answers, but clearly, they are not convincing. But one thing is sure. We have not heard the last of this issue in its present form.

Recent Posts

The government's bid to link women's reservation with delimitation masked political engineering. Framed as empowerment, it risked skewing federal balance and electoral power. Its defeat exposed a stra
apicture Oliver D'Souza
27 Apr 2026
You did not mention this rare parliamentary achievement in your address to the nation because it would have demolished your theory that the Congress and other parties you mentioned were against women'
apicture A. J. Philip
27 Apr 2026
A Bhopal seminar marked Swami Sadanand's legacy of interfaith harmony and reconciliation, highlighting his transformative compassion, grassroots impact, and enduring relevance in a conflict-ridden wor
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
27 Apr 2026
A proposed national Christian federation faces deep structural, theological, and political tensions, as diversity, institutional rivalry, and waning urgency over FCRA reforms expose the limits of unit
apicture John Dayal
27 Apr 2026
A wave of labour unrest since April 2026, sparked in Manesar, has spread across industrial hubs, driven by low wages, harsh conditions, and insecurity. Expanding participation reflects deeper structur
apicture Jose Vattakuzhy
27 Apr 2026
Fr Dr Antony Plackal, VC's "The Kingdom Inherited: A Christian Enthusiasm from The Last Judgment Scene" is a profound theological and spiritual exploration that draws readers into the heart of Christ'
apicture Fr Dr Antony Vadakkekara, VC
27 Apr 2026
What we are watching in the 2026 Tamil Nadu election is not a campaign. It is a production. A carefully managed, expensively funded content operation built to shape how people feel about a candidate b
apicture Dr. John Singarayar
27 Apr 2026
Pondicherry dust knows my black footsteps, how far they walked to see your brown face. Pondy flowers know how many roses my black hand carried to give to your brown hands.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
27 Apr 2026
Schoolchildren's disappointment and protest following a visit to a dazzling hybrid garden, lacking bees or butterflies, expose a deeper truth: beauty without life is hollow, and nature, stripped of ec
apicture P. A. Chacko
27 Apr 2026
The Mumbai police have decided to issue maroon T-shirts and shorts to male suspects lodged in central lockups. "It's an ingenious idea," said a police commissioner from another state in northern India
apicture Robert Clements
27 Apr 2026