hidden image

Mere Spectators in Football!

Robert Clements Robert Clements
20 Jul 2026

"Yippee!" screamed my neighbour.

I rushed to his house in the middle of the night, thinking the municipality had finally filled the pothole outside while the city slept.

"Yippee," he cried again, staring at the television. "Argentina won!"

Outside, the pothole continued widening. The street was flooding. A motorcyclist had disappeared briefly into a crater and emerged in another ward. But nobody cared. The Football World Cup was on.

For ninety minutes, India forgot everything.

We forgot our roads, our floods, our bridges and our drains. We watched countries obeying the same rules, playing on the same field and accepting the same referee.

Perhaps that is why India was not playing.

We are uncomfortable with games in which everybody follows identical rules.

It's only in cricket that we do rather well. But that's because, even the British, who invented it, occasionally look bored playing it.

Football is different. Nearly the whole world plays it. Everybody knows when the ball crosses the line. Nobody can announce that it was a goal merely because millions of supporters believe it was.

And that is where we have difficulty.

We want our own field, our own referee, our own scoreboard, and, preferably, an opposition that has already been disqualified.

We do the same with democracy.

The world says democracy means strong opposition, independent institutions, equality before the law, and a press free to question those in power.

We reply, "We hold elections."

"But what about the rest?"

"We won the elections."

That ends the discussion.

When international reports question our press freedom, equality or democratic health, we do not examine ourselves. We examine the report.

"Who prepared it?"

"Why do they hate India?"

"Were they funded by Pakistan?"

Soon, the report itself is on trial, while the problem it described slips quietly out of the courtroom.

It is like a footballer picking up the ball, running into the goal and then accusing the referee of being anti-national for blowing the whistle.

The world says, "That is handball."

We reply, "Not according to our ancient culture."

The world shows us statistics.

We show the world a speech.

The world points to inequality.

We point to a new temple.

The world asks about silenced journalists.

We turn up the volume of hate on television.

So we sit and watch the World Cup, cheering nations that accept common rules while refusing to play by those rules ourselves.

We are magnificent spectators. We clap for fair play abroad and practise foul play at home.

Then we organise our own match, lock out the referee, remove the opposition, announce the final score and declare ourselves world champions.

The potholes remain. The floods return. Democracy limps.

But the scoreboard looks excellent because we are the only ones allowed to operate it.

Mere spectators of the world. And permanent winners in games where we make the rules...

Recent Posts

Political independence was never Gandhi's final destination. He envisioned a Republic rooted in constitutional values, social justice and human dignity. Every Independence Day invites a single questio
apicture Joe Eruppakkatt
10 Aug 2026
The Arthashastra counsels engagement, accountability and informed leadership—not disappearance. A government that retreats from Parliament while students demand justice betrays not only democratic con
apicture A. J. Philip
10 Aug 2026
It should not be surprising when a generation denied its future by governments prioritising identity and ideology over employment, education, and opportunity transforms frustration into resistance and
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
10 Aug 2026
The battle over eggs is really a battle over India's priorities. A nation serious about defeating child malnutrition cannot allow ideology, caste prejudices, or religious taboos to determine what its
apicture John Dayal
10 Aug 2026
Branding the youth as "misled" is rich coming from a regime whose greatest political asset has been relentless propaganda. Social media narratives can manufacture consent, but they cannot manufacture
apicture Oliver D'Souza
10 Aug 2026
You appeared like a moon-flower in 2002, you shone like moonlight until 2004. Where did you go from Pondicherry? For so long, I searched for you among the moon-flowers.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
10 Aug 2026
During his visit to Seychelles, Modiji is reported to have spent time meeting the oldest living animal, a 194-year-old tortoise. But in India, he has no time to listen to the younger generation, the u
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
10 Aug 2026
Old men of India, listen carefully. The world has changed. Go home gracefully. And if you have no home to return to, build an old folk's home together. Sit comfortably, play recordings of how obedient
apicture Robert Clements
10 Aug 2026
No fascist order is truly invincible. Its strength rests upon fear, propaganda, and institutional takeover. Once those illusions are shattered by organised resistance, authoritarian power unravels wit
apicture Adv. Jijo Thomas Placheril
03 Aug 2026
Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation may have appeased public anger, but replacing one RSS ideologue with another exposes the government's strategy: sacrifice individuals, preserve ideology. The faces may
apicture Oliver D'Souza
03 Aug 2026