Banality of Indifference

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
20 Jul 2026

Sonam Wangchuk is starving, and in the meantime, the Republic is practising its art of looking the other way, much as it did in Manipur and elsewhere.

For over three weeks, one of the nation's distinguished educationists, environmental visionaries, and public intellectuals has subjected himself to the ultimate ultima ratio available within a constitutional democracy: the voluntary mortification of his own body. Each passing day records another medical bulletin chronicling muscular atrophy and physiological decline. Yet the sovereign response has been a silence so deliberate that it has taken on the character of public policy.

The historical juxtaposition is impossible to ignore. Barely a decade ago, Anna Hazare's anti-corruption fast was elevated into a national catharsis. It had seemed at the time that television studios had relocated almost permanently to his protest site.

Every slogan was breaking news and was amplified with religious fervour. Behind the ostensibly spontaneous mobilisation stood an extraordinarily disciplined organisational apparatus, meticulously nurtured by the Sangh Parivar. Masquerading as civil society, it metamorphosed into a regime change.

Wangchuk's fast has elicited neither even a proximate moral urgency nor sustained national attention. Mutatis mutandis, the disparity reveals an axiom of contemporary politics being played in the country: not every protest is permitted to mature into a movement. Some are canonised; others are quarantined. The asymmetry between them is not accidental.

Members of the All India Students' Association (AISA) have undertaken a parallel hunger strike for weeks under the same pitiless Delhi sky, enduring identical physiological deterioration and embracing equivalent personal sacrifice. Their names scarcely register beyond activist circles.

Around Jantar Mantar, dissent has itself undergone commodification. Politicians arrive to perform carefully choreographed acts of solidarity. Public intellectuals issue eloquent statements of concern, calibrated for maximum circulation and minimal consequence. Visitors queue for photographs against the backdrop of barricades. Protest has become a performance.

The Government has perhaps correctly concluded that temporal attrition favours incumbency. Each extra day without engagement is increasingly normalising executive intransigence.

The barricades erected around Jantar Mantar have become an apt metaphor for the ever-increasing distance between authority and accountability.
The gravest peril, however, extends beyond the fate of Sonam Wangchuk himself. Hannah Arendt reminded us that the greatest political evils often acquire the appearance of ordinary administrative actions. We are witnessing precisely such a moment.

The Government knows that it can simply outlast moral appeals because it has not risen to power on a moral appeal; it has risen on ugly polarisation. It knows that citizens will cease expecting power to respond to peaceful sacrifice because India, blinded by its ignorance, today wants temples where they may raise idols to power, not the ones imagined by Nehru or the freedom fighters and reformers.

Recent Posts

You may be supremely happy that your Freedom of Religion Bill has received the President's assent and has now come into force in Maharashtra. But there is an irony that you may not have noticed.
apicture A. J. Philip
31 Aug 2026
India's children are discovering the power of protest. Their demands are modest. Safe classrooms, clean water, toilets, teachers and dignity. If governments silence those who expose these failures rat
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
31 Aug 2026
Gonsalves was born on April 5, 1954, in Munnar, nestled in the Western Ghats in Idukki District of Kerala, into a prominent Anglo-Indian family from Pallippuram in Kochi's Vypin. He was the eldest son
apicture Renjith Leen
31 Aug 2026
A "church-free Odisha" must not become a cause for fear or retaliation. Christians must respond with truth, courage and peace, remembering that our strongest witness is faithful service: building brid
apicture Archbishop John Barwa, SVD
31 Aug 2026
Vande Mataram once united Indians against colonialism. Its appropriation today seeks to turn a shared national symbol into a test of Hindu nationalism and patriotism, diverting attention from governan
apicture Oliver D'Souza
31 Aug 2026
Recent cases of infants abandoned in Haryana, Karnataka and Jharkhand expose a legal system built for children who can speak, not infants who cannot. Strict criminal penalties for abandonment push par
apicture Vidyadhar Prabhudesai
31 Aug 2026
The smartphone may be the millstone of our age: a pocket-sized idol that promises connection but breeds distraction. When we surrender ourselves to its endless pull, children learn to imitate us. True
apicture Fr. Anil Prakash D'Souza, OP
31 Aug 2026
Dolly's faith was heard not only in gospel songs but also in her generosity. Through her Imagination Library, she placed millions of books into the hands of children. She did not merely sing about lov
apicture Robert Clements
31 Aug 2026
A democracy must distinguish between an armed insurgent and a questioning citizen. Calling critics, students, academics or activists "Dimaagi Naxals" is unacceptable. Strength lies not in silencing di
apicture Dr Martin Valiyaparambil VC
24 Aug 2026
As I watched, I could not help remembering the interview I did with your father, NKP Salve, for Jain TV in the 1990s. Goswami, I presume, was then still "studying for some time in a Jesuit-run school,
apicture A. J. Philip
24 Aug 2026