Faith Crushed : The Hypocrisy and Mismanagement Behind Kumbh Mela Tragedies

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
24 Feb 2025

"They were inviting us here to die" is a sentiment appalling to hear, however one tries to contextualise, embellish or rationalise it. It is as evocatively chilling as Jews being herded into gas chambers during the Nazi regime. This statement was made by a farmer who survived, describing the crowd crush at the 2025 Kumbh Mela in India. Even the farmer realised that the event was grossly mismanaged and that the administrative priorities were focused on VIPs instead of ordinary devotees.

Driven by their ideological pathology, the Nazis persecuted those whom they considered the other and did not fall in line with their diktats. The people were forced into camps. The Kumbh is a mega event that has, in near history, never been stampede-free. Instead of implementing crowd-control measures, the government decided it would serve their best interests to prioritise a swelling attendance, leveraging it to grow political capital. The people willingly reciprocated in overwhelming numbers, believing that the "champions" of Hindutva would receive them following the adage atithi devo bhava—"a guest is a god."

Clearly, the remarks of the administration at the state and national levels reveal their disconnect from reality and human nature. No sympathy or familiarity has crossed their minds even after the disaster. Whether it be Hema Malini trying to downplay it as a minor incident and doubling down on trivialising it or the administration claiming that the Kumbh is an unparalleled success, Hindu unity is only a political handle that these proponents of faith use to hold onto votes.

The government is going far to ensure the erasure of the stampedes at the Mela at Prayagraj and the New Delhi Railway Station. The administration initially acted as if nothing had happened. It was not until the media started covering it that they acknowledged the incident. Independent media and individuals from ground zero report numbers far more than the official claims. The Railways have gone as far as to issue takedown notices to social media channel(s) to remove videos of the stampede and its aftermath. The notice claims that the actual videos are misleading and may lead to a situation of law and order.

Noticeably, this incident has not created a significant stir within the populace. People who vociferously protest against providing education and healthcare to the downtrodden, claiming conversion, are nowhere heard. These elements cry themselves hoarse that people are being lured by other faiths, even against statistics that prove otherwise. Yet, they did not make a move when the actions of their own leaders were crushing their own brethren, even when evident.

Videos depicting minorities as villains are being circulated openly by fundamentalists. No takedown notices have been filed to remove them. Are they not far worse, being false and incendiary? The blatant hypocrisy of Hindutva leaders is laid bare for all to see. They shut down what is true and propagate what is false. Still, can we expect the citizenry to open their eyes and see that the leaders they support are not what they think they are?

Recent Posts

Close at the heel of our other neighbours, Nepal's journey has swung between hope and betrayal. The monarchy fell, the republic faltered, and now its youth demand dignity, justice, and a future free f
apicture A. J. Philip
15 Sep 2025
The recent Vice-Presidential election has exposed deep cracks in India's democracy. Cross-voting, intimidation, abstentions, and invalid ballots have raised serious doubts. It ultimately begs the ques
apicture M L Satyan
15 Sep 2025
September 11 carries memories of violence and division, but also of Gandhi's Satyagraha and Vivekananda's call to end fanaticism. In a world scarred by war, injustice, and hate, 9/11 must challenge us
apicture Cedric Prakash
15 Sep 2025
India may soon become the world's third-largest economy, but its low per capita income, unmitigated inequality, weak healthcare, and fragile education system reveal a different truth. GDP milestones a
apicture Jacob Peenikaparambil
15 Sep 2025
Modi's long-delayed visit to Manipur are mere optics. After two years of silence amid ethnic cleansing, displacement, and inhumanity by the Meiteis, what peace, protection of minorities, and restorati
apicture Dr Manoj Kumar Mishra
15 Sep 2025
Umar Khalid, the Jawaharlal Nehru University scholar who has spent more than five years in jail, on Thursday, September 11, told a Delhi court that the larger Conspiracy case in connection with the 20
apicture Joseph Maliakan
15 Sep 2025
Looking back at the 100 years of Medical Mission Sisters, there was a pioneering spirit to begin health care facilities for the less privileged, openness to look at themselves critically to make their
apicture Sr. Mary Pullattu, MMS
15 Sep 2025
Though declared a secular republic in 2008, the nation's legal and cultural frameworks remain steeped in Hindu-majority sentiment. Nepal's National Penal Code of 2017 criminalises religious conversion
apicture CM Paul
15 Sep 2025
To be a "Carmelite on the street" is to unite deep prayer with public courage. We must build interior castles yet opening their gates, carrying contemplation into classrooms, farms, protests, and parl
apicture Gisel Erumachadathu, ASI
15 Sep 2025
In today's India, more than flyovers or metros, what we desperately need are bridges. Bridges between communities. Bridges between faiths. Bridges strong enough to carry us into the future without col
apicture Robert Clements
15 Sep 2025