The Mirror India Refuses to Face

Fr. Gaurav Nair Fr. Gaurav Nair
17 Nov 2025

The World Day of the Poor arrives each year as an indictment. It calls us to look, without pretence, at a truth we dodge daily: the poor are not the margins of society. They are its foundation. And yet, in our country, they remain the most neglected, the most misrepresented, and often the most punished.

Every civilisation has grappled with its duty to the poor. Ancient codes, village customs, and religious traditions all carried some form of obligation. No tradition has articulated it with the moral clarity the Catholic Church has offered through the centuries, which it yet fails spectacularly.

Pope Leo XIII, in Rerum Novarum, insisted that the cry of the worker and the poor should disturb the conscience of the powerful. He understood that societies unravel when the strong treat the weak as expendable.

Pope Francis sharpened this further. For him, the poor are not simply "a concern." They are the central horizon. He urges a "fundamental option for the poor," a phrase often misunderstood. It does not mean charity as a seasonal gesture. It means structuring our priorities, institutions, and politics so that the poor are at the heart of our decisions, not an afterthought.

This is where India falters.

Across the country, the poor build our cities, feed our markets, clean our waste, stitch our clothes, and serve our illusions of modernity. Yet they live in the shadows—migrant workers who vanish between censuses, fisherfolk battling rising seas and shrinking incomes, Dalit Christians and Muslims shut out of constitutional protections, and families who depend on erratic welfare systems that treat them as numbers, not citizens.

Their lives do not fail because of personal shortcomings. They fail because public systems designed for them crumble with predictable regularity.

Look at our skilling programmes, once announced with great flourish. Many young Indians enrolled with the hope of stepping out of generational hardship. They imagined wages, dignity, and a future they could claim as their own. Yet scams, ghost trainees, and inflated claims reduced those dreams to ash. Certificates were handed out without training. Training centres existed only on paper. A mission intended to uplift the poor became yet another case study in how power bends public schemes to private greed.

On the other hand, caste—our oldest wound—continues to shape who suffers and who survives. Dalit Christians, despite baptism, remain chained to discrimination both outside and within the Church. The struggle of 75 years has yielded little change. Their hope for justice collides with a state unwilling to confront caste within Christianity because it would unravel too many political calculations.

The World Day of the Poor stands as a counter-message to such indifference. It declares that the poor are not objects of pity but subjects of justice. It reminds us that God walks with them long before He walks into any sanctuary. To ignore them is to walk away from our own humanity.

If we wish to call ourselves a moral nation, we must first listen to the people we have pushed aside. The poor do not need sermons. They need a state that works, a society that sees them, and a Church that stands beside them without hesitation or fear. Only then can this day be more than a ritual. It can be a reckoning—and, perhaps, a beginning.

Recent Posts

Communal hatred, seeded by colonial divide-and-rule and revived by modern majoritarianism, is corroding India's syncretic culture. Yet acts of everyday courage remind us that constitutional values and
apicture Ram Puniyani
16 Feb 2026
What appears as cultural homage is, in fact, political signalling. By elevating Vande Mataram symbolism over inclusion, the state is diminishing the national anthem, unsettling hard-won consensus, and
apicture A. J. Philip
16 Feb 2026
States are increasingly becoming laboratories of hate; the experiment will ultimately consume the nation itself. The choice before India is stark: reaffirm constitutional citizenship, or allow adminis
apicture John Dayal
16 Feb 2026
Mamata Banerjee's personal appearance before the Supreme Court of India has transformed a procedural dispute over SIR into a constitutional warning—questioning whether institutions meant to safeguard
apicture Oliver D'Souza
16 Feb 2026
This is a book by two redoubtable Jesuit scholars. Lancy Lobo is currently the Research Director of the Indian Social Institute in New Delhi, while Denzil Fernandes was its former Executive Director.
apicture Chhotebhai
16 Feb 2026
The cry "Why am I poor?" exposes a world where fear of the other, corrupted politics, and dollar-driven power reduce millions to "children of a lesser god." Abundance will coexist with deprivation, an
apicture Peter Fernandes
16 Feb 2026
O Water! There is a facade of democracy. In which caste is appropriated As a religious tool, To strengthen the caste hierarchy For touching their water.
apicture Dr Suryaraju Mattimalla
16 Feb 2026
From Washington's muscle diplomacy to Hindutva's cultural majoritarianism, a dangerous erosion of values is reshaping global and Indian politics. When power replaces principle and identity overrides j
apicture Thomas Menamparampil
16 Feb 2026
In today's world, governance is not merely about policies. It is about performance. The teleprompter screen must glow. The sentences must glide. The applause must arrive on cue.
apicture Robert Clements
16 Feb 2026
From Godhra to Assam, a once-neutral word has been weaponised to stigmatise, harass, and exclude a section of the people. This is not a linguistic accident but a political design wherein power turns l
apicture A. J. Philip
09 Feb 2026